| EERIE | A little too quiet, perhaps |
| EERIE | Almost too coincidental |
| EERIE | Amazingly coincidental |
| EERIE | Appropriate for Halloween |
| EERIE | Arcane |
| EERIE | Arousing goose bumps |
| EERIE | Beyond unusual |
| EERIE | Bizarre |
| EERIE | Bizarre and unreal |
| EERIE | Bone-chilling |
| EERIE | Capable of causing nightmares, maybe |
| EERIE | Causing a chill |
| EERIE | Causing chills |
| EERIE | Causing goose bumps |
| EERIE | Causing goose pimples |
| EERIE | Causing goosebumps |
| EERIE | Causing shivers, perhaps |
| EERIE | Causing the creeps |
| EERIE | Causing the willies |
| EERIE | Chilling |
| EERIE | Chilling, in a way |
| EERIE | Chillingly strange |
| EERIE | Chill-inducing |
| EERIE | Chill-inducing, say |
| EERIE | Coincidental, in an unsettling way |
| EERIE | Creepy |
| EERIE | Creepy European lake |
| EERIE | Creepy and weird |
| EERIE | Creepy, like a haunted house |
| EERIE | Creepy-sounding lake |
| EERIE | Evoking goose bumps, say |
| EERIE | Extraterrestrial |
| EERIE | Fear-inspiring |
| EERIE | Frightening, like a haunted house |
| EERIE | Frightening, uncanny |
| EERIE | Frighteningly odd |
| EERIE | Frightfully bizarre |
| EERIE | Frightfully strange |
| EERIE | Fright-causing |
| EERIE | Ghastly strange |
| EERIE | Ghostlike |
| EERIE | Ghostly |
| EERIE | Ghostly and mysterious |
| EERIE | Ghostly strange |
| EERIE | Ghostly, unreal |
| EERIE | Giving goose bumps, say |
| EERIE | Giving goosebumps |
| EERIE | Goose bumps-producing, maybe |
| EERIE | Goosebumps-inducing |
| EERIE | Goosebump-inducing |
| EERIE | Goosebump-raising |
| EERIE | Gooseflesh-making |
| EERIE | Hair-raising |
| EERIE | Halloweenish |
| EERIE | Halloweenlike |
| EERIE | Haunted |
| EERIE | Haunting |
| EERIE | Hauntingly familiar |
| EERIE | Hauntingly strange |
| EERIE | Having a chill factor? |
| EERIE | Hitchcockian |
| EERIE | Inducing gooseflesh |
| EERIE | Inspiring fear |
| EERIE | Kind of silence |
| EERIE | Like "Dark Shadows" episodes |
| EERIE | Like "Goosebumps" stories |
| EERIE | Like "Goosebumps" tales |
| EERIE | Like "The Shining," e.g. |
| EERIE | Like "The Twilight Zone" episodes |
| EERIE | Like "The Twilight Zone" music |
| EERIE | Like "The X-Files" |
| EERIE | Like "Twilight Zone" episodes |
| EERIE | Like 14-Across |
| EERIE | Like H. P. Lovecraft stories |
| EERIE | Like H. P. Lovecraft's writing |
| EERIE | Like Halloween sounds |
| EERIE | Like King movies |
| EERIE | Like Netflix's "Stranger Things" |
| EERIE | Like Poe stories |
| EERIE | Like Poe tales |
| EERIE | Like Poe's work |
| EERIE | Like Rod Serling tales |
| EERIE | Like Rod Serling's stories |
| EERIE | Like Serling stories |
| EERIE | Like Stephen King novels |
| EERIE | Like Stephen King's novels |
| EERIE | Like TV's "Tales From the Crypt" |
| EERIE | Like a Clive Barker novel |
| EERIE | Like a Dean Koontz novel |
| EERIE | Like a King story |
| EERIE | Like a Stephen King novel |
| EERIE | Like a call from someone one just thought about |
| EERIE | Like a coincidence that makes you go "Hmm ..." |
| EERIE | Like a coincidence that raises the hair on the back of your neck |
| EERIE | Like a ghost's howling |
| EERIE | Like a graveyard at midnight |
| EERIE | Like a haunted house |
| EERIE | Like a haunted place |
| EERIE | Like a portrait that seems to be watching you |
| EERIE | Like a wolf's howl |
| EERIE | Like a wolf's howl in the dead of night |
| EERIE | Like an empty ship at sea |
| EERIE | Like déjà vu |
| EERIE | Like freakish coincidences |
| EERIE | Like ghost sightings |
| EERIE | Like ghost stories |
| EERIE | Like ghostly sounds |
| EERIE | Like haunted houses |
| EERIE | Like howls in a haunted house |
| EERIE | Like many "Buffy" settings |
| EERIE | Like many 32-Across works |
| EERIE | Like many a campfire story |
| EERIE | Like many an omen |
| EERIE | Like many campfire tales |
| EERIE | Like much of Poe's work |
| EERIE | Like premonitions |
| EERIE | Like some coincidences |
| EERIE | Like some extreme coincidences |
| EERIE | Like some fogs |
| EERIE | Like some similarities |
| EERIE | Like tales of ghost ships |
| EERIE | Like the musical intro to "The Twilight Zone" |
| EERIE | Like the theme music for "The Twilight Zone" |
| EERIE | Like the vampire film "Let the Right One In" |
| EERIE | Like things that go bump in the night |
| EERIE | Likely to creep one out |
| EERIE | Macbeth, at times |
| EERIE | Mighty strange |
| EERIE | More than a little strange |
| EERIE | Mysterious |
| EERIE | Mysterious, scary |
| EERIE | Mysteriously spooky |
| EERIE | Not explainable |
| EERIE | Odd |
| EERIE | Oddly scary |
| EERIE | Otherworldly |
| EERIE | Out of this world |
| EERIE | Paranormal, say |
| EERIE | Peculiar |
| EERIE | Phantasmal |
| EERIE | Poe-ish |
| EERIE | Preternatural |
| EERIE | Producing goosebumps |
| EERIE | Raising goose bumps |
| EERIE | Raising goose pimples |
| EERIE | Really creepy |
| EERIE | Really spooky |
| EERIE | Really strange |
| EERIE | Reminiscent of an alien landscape |
| EERIE | Scary |
| EERIE | Shivers-inducing |
| EERIE | Shiver-inducing |
| EERIE | Shiver-producing |
| EERIE | Sinister |
| EERIE | Sinister, ghostly |
| EERIE | Sort of scary |
| EERIE | Spine-chilling |
| EERIE | Spine-chillingly creepy |
| EERIE | Spine-tingling |
| EERIE | Spine-tinglingly strange |
| EERIE | Spooky |
| EERIE | Spooky and unsettling |
| EERIE | Spooky, gives an uneasy vibe |
| EERIE | Spo-o-o-oky |
| EERIE | Strange |
| EERIE | Strange and frightening |
| EERIE | Strange and unsettling |
| EERIE | Strange, in a creepy kind of way |
| EERIE | Strangely coincidental, say |
| EERIE | Strangely scary |
| EERIE | Strangely spooky |
| EERIE | Stranger than strange |
| EERIE | Suggestive of the supernatural |
| EERIE | Supernatural |
| EERIE | Supernatural or freakish |
| EERIE | Supernaturally strange |
| EERIE | Uncanny |
| EERIE | Unearthly |
| EERIE | Unexplainable |
| EERIE | Unexplainable, maybe |
| EERIE | Unnatural |
| EERIE | Unnatural, in a way |
| EERIE | Unnatural, mysterious |
| EERIE | Unnerving, perhaps |
| EERIE | Unsettling |
| EERIE | Unsettling, in a way |
| EERIE | Unsettling, say |
| EERIE | Unsettlingly strange |
| EERIE | Very odd indeed |
| EERIE | Very peculiar |
| EERIE | Very strange |
| EERIE | Weird |
| EERIE | Weird and creepy |
| EERIE | Weird and frightening |
| EERIE | Weird and spooky |
| EERIE | Weird in a creepy way |
| EERIE | Weird in a scary way |
| EERIE | Weird, in a chilling way |
| EERIE | Weirdly spooky |
| EERIE | À la King |
| EERIE | À la King? |
| EERIE | À la Poe |