| 100% | FEAR | 4 | "(Don't ___) The Reaper," song by Blue Oyster Cult that a grim reaper might sing at Fright Night Karaoke |
| 58% | LIVING | 6 | "The ___ Dead," song by No More Kings that a zombie might sing at Fright Night Karaoke |
| 57% | MOON | 4 | "Bark at the ___," song by Ozzy Osbourne that a werewolf might sing at Fright Night Karaoke |
| 57% | BONE | 4 | "Bad to the ___," song by George Thorogood and the Destroyers that a skeleton might sing at Fright Night Karaoke |
| 53% | SPELL | 5 | "I Put a ___ on You," song by "Screamin' Jay" Hawkins that a witch might sing at Fright Night Karaoke |
| 51% | BLOOD | 5 | "Riboflavin-Flavored, Non-Carbonated, Polyunsaturated ___," song covered by 45 Grave that a vampire might sing at Fright Night Karaoke |
| 42% | FEAR | 4 | "(Don't ___) The Reaper" (classic song by Blue Öyster Cult) |
| 35% | PIE | 3 | "American ___," song by Don McLean that a chef might sing while whipping up a lemon meringue dessert |
| 35% | CAKE | 4 | "___ by the Ocean," pop song by DNCE that a pastry chef might sing while frosting a chocolate sponge dessert |
| 32% | CULT | 4 | Don't Fear the Reaper band Blue Oyster __ |
| 32% | CASTLES | 7 | "___ in the Air," 1971 song by Don McLean that was a Billboard Top 40 hit |
| 30% | YAKETYYAK | 9 | Lyric that precedes “don’t talk back” in a 1958 hit song by the Coasters |
| 30% | STOP | 4 | "Don't ___," 1977 song by Fleetwood Mac that peaked at No. 3 on the Billboard Hot 100 |
| 30% | HIPS | 4 | "___ Don't Lie," 2006 song by Shakira that topped the Billboard Hot 100 |
| 30% | DIGGING | 7 | "___ in the Dirt," song by Peter Gabriel that might bring out your green thumb and a few wiggly worms |
| 29% | FEAR | 4 | "(Don't ___) The Reaper" (Blue Öyster Cult hit) |
| 29% | LONELY | 6 | "___ Night (Angel Face)," 1975 song by Neil Sedaka that peaked at No. 3 on the U.S. Billboard Hot 100 |
| 29% | LIFE | 4 | "Love of My ___," 1975 song by Queen which is a part of the album "A Night At the Opera" |
| 29% | NOW | 3 | "___ I'm A Farmer," song by the Who that might bring out your green thumb and fresh homegrown veggies |
| 29% | SUN | 3 | "Don't Let the ___ Go Down on Me," 1974 song by Elton John that peaked at No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 |
| 29% | BOOK | 4 | "Cooking by the ___," LazyTown song a chef might sing while consulting a recipe manual for every tasty dish in this puzzle |
| 28% | THIS | 4 | "___ Is It," theme song sung by Polly Cutter in the 1975 series "One Day at a Time" |
| 28% | CAR | 3 | "I'm In Love With My ___," 1975 song by Queen which is a part of the album "A Night at the Opera" |
| 28% | FROZEN | 6 | 1998 song by Madonna that peaked at No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 with lyrics about a cold and emotionless man |
| 28% | DUETS | 5 | Songs a couple might perform at karaoke |
| 28% | KNOWMYNAME | 10 | "I Don't ___," the original song sung by 17a for the audition of "America's Got Talent": 3 wds. |
| 28% | MUCH | 4 | "That Don't Impress Me ___," 1998 song by Shania Twain that refers to Brad Pitt in the lyrics |
| 28% | UNDER | 5 | "___ the Bridge," 1992 song by the Red Hot Chili Peppers, with a music video that won two awards at the 1992 MTV Video Music Awards |
| 28% | LIE | 3 | "Hips Don't ___" (hit song performed by Shakira at the 2020 Super Bowl halftime show) |
| 28% | CHICKEN | 7 | "___ Fried," song by Zac Brown Band that a chef might hum while making buffalo wings |