| 100% | BOXOF | 5 | "... like a ___ chocolates" |
| 95% | MOLTEN | 6 | Like a chocolate lava cake's center |
| 95% | RICH | 4 | Loaded, like a chocolate cake |
| 92% | RICH | 4 | Like a German chocolate cake |
| 91% | KITKAT | 6 | Android OS version like a chocolate wafer biscuit |
| 87% | UNWRAP | 6 | Open, like a bar of chocolate |
| 86% | BLONDIE | 7 | Dessert like a brownie but without chocolate |
| 85% | LIFEIS | 6 | Forrest Gump maxim, __ like a box of chocolates |
| 83% | BOX | 3 | "Life is like a ___ of chocolates" ("Forrest Gump" line) |
| 83% | ANALOGY | 7 | "Life is like a box of chocolates," e.g. |
| 83% | ANALOGY | 7 | "Life is like a box of chocolates," for example |
| 83% | ASSORTED | 8 | With many different varieties, like a box of chocolates |
| 82% | ASSORTED | 8 | Like chocolates in a sampler |
| 82% | ICED | 4 | Like many a chocolate cake |
| 82% | ASSORTED | 8 | With lots of different kinds, like a box of chocolates |
| 80% | EMINEM | 6 | "Lose Yourself" rapper whose name sounds like a brand of chocolate |
| 79% | GOOEY | 5 | Like the inside of a warm chocolate chip cookie |
| 79% | BITTERSWEET | 11 | Like chocolate with a high cacao percentage |
| 77% | ROLO | 4 | Chocolate shaped like a truncated cone |
| 74% | ROLO | 4 | Chocolate candy shaped like a lampshade |
| 70% | MOUSSECALL | 10 | "Wow, Mom, this is like at a restaurant! Dibs on the chocolate pudding!" |
| 69% | TRUFFLE | 7 | Chocolate ganache treat named like a fungus |
| 67% | PART | 4 | Like a --> |
| 66% | OOZING | 6 | Trickling, like lava from a chocolate lava cake |
| 65% | MALE | 4 | Like a stag |
| 65% | DIG | 3 | Like a heap |
| 65% | EAGER | 5 | Like a beaver |
| 65% | TALL | 4 | Like a skyscraper |
| 65% | SCALY | 5 | Like a dragon |
| 65% | TOOGOODTOBETRUE | 15 | Like a dream |