| 100% | PEANUT | 6 | "___ Butter Jelly," Buckwheat Boyz's popular meme song referring sandwich-spreads that was featured on "Family Guy" |
| 29% | OVERDRIVE | 9 | 2003 song by Katy Rose that was featured on the "Mean Girls" soundtrack |
| 29% | MILKSHAKE | 9 | 2003 song by singer Kelis that was featured on the "Mean Girls" soundtrack |
| 28% | SPIKE | 5 | Golden ___, iconic railroad piece that was featured on Utah's 50 State quarter |
| 27% | OLD | 3 | ___ Man of the Mountain, former landmark that was featured on New Hampshire's 50 State quarter |
| 27% | PRICE | 5 | Horror star Vincent who was featured on Michael Jackson's song "Thriller" |
| 27% | JAMS | 4 | Spreads that are similar to jellies |
| 26% | LSD | 3 | 1960s drug that was featured on "Mad Men": Abbr. |
| 26% | JINGLEBELL | 10 | "___ Rock," Christmas song that was featured on the "Mean Girls" soundtrack: 2 wds. |
| 26% | LOON | 4 | Common ___, Minnesota's state bird that was featured on its 50 State quarter |
| 25% | TYLER | 5 | Carti was featured on his song "Earfquake" |
| 25% | HUMP | 4 | Camel's ___, Green Mountains peak that was featured on Vermont's 50 State quarter |
| 25% | GOTTA | 5 | "Something's ___ Give," 2005 LeAnn Rimes song that was featured on the US Billboard Hot 100 |
| 25% | JACK | 4 | Union ___, U.K. flag that is featured on the state flag of Hawaii |
| 24% | BUILT | 5 | "___ This Way," 2004 song by Samantha Ronson that was featured on the "Mean Girls" soundtrack |
| 24% | BIG | 3 | ___ Dipper, stars of the Ursa Major constellation that are featured on the state flag of Alaska |
| 24% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that was previously popular |
| 24% | SCOOBY | 6 | "___-Doo," media franchise that was featured in an animated crossover episode on "Supernatural" |
| 23% | PEANUT | 6 | "___ Butter Jelly Time" (novelty song in an old internet meme) |
| 23% | GOTTOGIVEITUP | 13 | Song by Marvin Gaye that was #20 on Billboard's year-end Hot 100 for 1977: 5 wds. |
| 23% | BESTOFMYLOVE | 12 | Song by the Emotions that was #3 on Billboard's year-end Hot 100 for 1977: 4 wds. |
| 23% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that was popular way back when |
| 23% | THETOP | 6 | "That song has been on ___ charts for a while..." (List of popular songs): 2 wds. |
| 23% | LAS | 3 | "___ Mananitas," song that may be dedicated to mothers in Mexico on Mother's Day |
| 23% | GOODASYOU | 9 | 2019 single that was Kane Brown's fourth consecutive #1 song on the "Billboard" Country Airplay chart (3 wds.) |
| 23% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that was popular back in the day |
| 23% | KIMBRA | 6 | Featured artist on Gotye's "Somebody That I Used to Know," the #8 song of the 2010s |
| 23% | GODSPLAN | 8 | Drake song that was #1 on Billboard's 2018 Year-End Hot 100: 2 wds. |
| 23% | CARS | 4 | "Chasing ___," song by Snow Patrol that was featured in "Grey's Anatomy" |
| 23% | DSL | 3 | Internet connection that is frequently referred to as "always on" : Abbr. |