| 100% | GONE | 4 | "___ Girl," 2014 psychological thriller directed by David Fincher that follows a man who becomes a suspect after his wife disappears |
| 44% | THEBRAVEONE | 11 | 2007 psychological thriller directed by Neil Jordan that follows the story of a radio host who becomes a vigilante after a tragic incident: 3 wds. |
| 40% | OUT | 3 | "Get ___," 2017 psychological thriller directed by Jordan Peele that follows a man whose girlfriend has a secret |
| 39% | LAMBS | 5 | "Silence of The ___," 1991 psychological thriller directed by Jonathan Demme that follows a detective who seeks help from an infamous prisoner |
| 38% | GIRL | 4 | "Gone ___," psychological thriller film where a husband becomes the primary suspect after his wife mysteriously disappears |
| 36% | SON | 3 | "The Good ___," 1993 psychological thriller directed by Joseph Ruben that follows the story of a 12-year-old and his psychopathic cousin |
| 35% | TAXI | 4 | "___ Driver," 1976 psychological thriller directed by Martin Scorsese that follows a veteran planning multiple assassinations |
| 33% | GONE | 4 | "___ Girl," 2014 thriller film directed by David Fincher starring Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike |
| 31% | SHUTTERISLAND | 13 | 2010 psychological thriller directed by Martin Scorsese that follows the story of a U.S. Marshal's investigation of a psychiatric facility: 2 wds. |
| 29% | THEPRESTIGE | 11 | 2006 psychological thriller directed by Christopher Nolan that follows the story of rival magicians: 2 wds. |
| 26% | TIMETRAVELERS | 13 | "The ___ Wife," bestselling debut novel by Audrey Niffenegger published in 2003 about a man who moves through time and his wife: 2 wds. |
| 26% | PANIC | 5 | "___ Room," 2002 thriller directed by David Fincher |
| 25% | GONEGIRL | 8 | 2014 David Fincher thriller featuring a Grammy- and Golden Globe-nominated score by the members of 32-Across (2 wds.) |
| 25% | THEFALLEN | 9 | Thriller novel by David Baldacci which was part of "Memory Man" series and became a NYT 2018 Bestseller: 2 wds. |
| 25% | MULHOLLANDDRIVE | 15 | 2001 neo-noir psychological thriller directed by David Lynch |
| 25% | GIRL | 4 | "Gone ___," 2014 movie directed by David Fincher |
| 24% | GONEGIRL | 8 | 2014 American psychological thriller co-produced by Reese Witherspoon that was adapted from a Gillian Flynn novel: 2 wds. |
| 24% | WIDOWER | 7 | A man who has lost his wife |
| 24% | BIRD | 4 | "Lady ___," 2017 film directed by Greta Gerwig that follows a high schooler and her mother |
| 24% | CREEP | 5 | 2014 found footage film that follows a videographer who responds to an ad |
| 24% | ROOM | 4 | "Panic ___," 2002 thriller film directed by David Fincher starring Jodie Foster |
| 23% | SEVEN | 5 | 1995 crime thriller film directed by David Fincher starring Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman |
| 23% | SWAN | 4 | "Black ___," 2010 psychological thriller, directed by Darren Aronofsky that stars Natalie Portman |
| 22% | GONE | 4 | Like the title girl in a 2014 David Fincher film |
| 22% | BOYS | 4 | "To All the ___ I've Loved Before," 2014 novel by Jenny Han that follows a teen's love life |
| 22% | CHEF | 4 | 2014 film starring Jon Favreau about a man operating a food truck after losing his restaurant job |
| 21% | HAT | 3 | "The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a ___" (Oliver Sacks book) |
| 21% | SACKS | 5 | "The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat" writer Oliver |
| 21% | OLIVER | 6 | "The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat" writer Sacks |
| 21% | CANDIDA | 7 | Comedy play written by George Bernard Shaw in 1894 that revolves around the lives of a clergyman and his wife |