| 100% | SEASONS | 7 | "___ of Love" (song from the Broadway musical "Rent") |
| 80% | RENT | 4 | Broadway musical with the song "Seasons of Love" |
| 68% | ASTIMEGOESBY | 12 | Song originally from the Broadway musical "Everybody's Welcome" |
| 66% | AIDA | 4 | Broadway musical with the song "The Gods Love Nubia" |
| 66% | MAMMAMIA | 8 | Broadway musical featuring the songs of 39-Down (2 wds.) |
| 60% | PROUDMARY | 9 | Girl in a Tina Turner song from the soundtrack of "What's Love Got to Do with It": 2 wds. |
| 59% | BEAUTIFUL | 9 | Current Broadway musical about Carole King's life (and the title of one of her hit songs) |
| 58% | MEIN | 4 | "___ Herr," iconic dance number from the Broadway musical "Cabaret" |
| 58% | RENT | 4 | Musical with the song "Seasons of Love" |
| 58% | RENT | 4 | Musical featuring the song "Seasons of Love" |
| 57% | YODEL | 5 | Song from the top of a mountain, often |
| 57% | STEP | 4 | "___ in Time," iconic dance number from the Broadway musical "Mary Poppins" |
| 57% | MOURNS | 6 | Song from the musical Wicked, No One __ The Wicked |
| 57% | KILDAREWASYOU | 13 | Song from the Irish version of The Music Man? |
| 56% | GRAVITY | 7 | Defying __, hit song from the musical Wicked |
| 56% | BANGLES | 7 | Baubles, __ & Beads, song from the musical Kismet |
| 56% | BAUBLES | 7 | __, Bangles & Beads, song from the musical Kismet |
| 56% | MEMORY | 6 | Most famous song from the musical Cats |
| 56% | JUICE | 5 | Song from 46-Across's album "Cuz I Love You" that won the 2019 Soul Train Music Award for Video of the Year |
| 56% | RENT | 4 | Musical known for the song "Seasons of Love" |
| 56% | BANGKOK | 7 | One Night in __, song from the musical Chess |
| 56% | CATS | 4 | Broadway musical featuring the song "Memory" |
| 56% | PHANTOM | 7 | Broadway musical The __ of the Opera |
| 55% | AGES | 4 | "Rock of ___" (jukebox musical featuring songs from the 1980s) |
| 55% | RISING | 6 | Hit song from the Animals: "House of the __ Sun" |
| 55% | RENT | 4 | Broadway musical with the song "Will I?" |
| 55% | PIPPIN | 6 | Broadway musical about the son of Charlemagne |
| 55% | WICKED | 6 | Broadway musical about the witches of Oz |
| 55% | AGE | 3 | "___ of Aquarius" (song from the musical "Hair") |
| 54% | ASOFT | 5 | "___ Place to Land," song from the musical "Waitress": 2 wds. |