| 100% | SHED | 4 | "___ Rather Be With Me" (1967 hit) |
| 100% | SHED | 4 | "_____ Rather Be With Me" (1967 hit) |
| 69% | IMAMAN | 6 | 1967 hit with the repeated lyric "Yes I am / And I can't help / But love you so" |
| 55% | NSYNC | 5 | *Group with the 2000 #1 hit "It's Gonna Be Me" |
| 55% | CREEP | 5 | Radiohead hit song with the lyric "I wish I was special" |
| 54% | NSYNC | 5 | Pop group with the No. 1 hit "It's Gonna Be Me" |
| 54% | GYPSY | 5 | 1959 Broadway hit with the song "All I Need Is the Girl" |
| 54% | FOREIGNER | 9 | Rock band with 80s hit I Want To Know What Love Is |
| 53% | HEYYA | 5 | OutKast hit with the lyric "Lend me some sugar, I am your neighbor!" |
| 53% | ELSE | 4 | "Who ___ is with me?" |
| 52% | SUPERTROUPER | 12 | ABBA hit with the lyric "All I do is eat and sleep and sing" |
| 51% | FASTCAR | 7 | Tracy Chapman hit with the line "I had a feeling I could be someone" (1988) |
| 51% | CARDIGAN | 8 | Hit single from 15-Across with the lyrics "You put me on and said I was your favorite" |
| 51% | CARDIGAN | 8 | Taylor Swift hit with the lyric "You put me on and said I was your favorite" |
| 50% | STAY | 4 | "___ With Me" (2014 Sam Smith hit) |
| 50% | CHARLENE | 8 | Singer with a one hit wonder I've Never Been to Me |
| 50% | OUGHT | 5 | Al Green’s “You ___ To Be With Me” |
| 50% | ALIBIED | 7 | Said, "She was with me all day," say |
| 50% | NIGHTFEVER | 10 | 1978 #1 hit with the lyrics "Here I am, praying for this moment to last": 2 wds. |
| 50% | OLDMAN | 6 | Neil Young hit with the lyrics “Look at my life / I’m a lot like you were” |
| 49% | STAY | 4 | "___ With Me" (Sam Smith hit) |
| 49% | NSYNC | 5 | Boy band with the #1 hit "It's Gonna Be Me" |
| 49% | ROYALS | 6 | 2013 Lorde hit song with the lyrics "Let me be your ruler, you can call me Queen B" |
| 49% | IRIS | 4 | Hit song for the Goo Goo Dolls with the repeated line "I just want you to know who I am" |
| 49% | CARDIGAN | 8 | Taylor Swift hit with the lyric "You put me on and said I was your favorite" |
| 49% | REDDY | 5 | Helen with the 1972 #1 hit "I Am Woman" |
| 49% | MEMORY | 6 | Barbra Streisand hit song with the lyrics "I can smile at the old days / I was beautiful then" |
| 49% | SUSIEQ | 6 | 1968 hit whose title is repeated three times with "Oh" and then again after "Baby I love you" |
| 48% | HOLDITAGAINST | 13 | "___ Me," a hit single from Britney's seventh album, "Femme Fatale," that was co-written with Bonnie McKee: 3 wds. |
| 48% | STAY | 4 | "___ With Me," hit song by Sam Smith |