| 100% | TRY | 3 | "___ Sleeping With a Broken Heart" (Alicia Keys song) |
| 58% | CAN | 3 | "I ___ Do It With a Broken Heart" (Taylor Swift song) |
| 48% | MEND | 4 | Repair, as a broken heart (rhymes with "send") |
| 48% | NOONE | 5 | "___ Mends a Broken Heart Like You" (Barbara Mandrell song) |
| 47% | ASIAM | 5 | Alicia Keys album with the song "No One" |
| 44% | GIRLONFIRE | 10 | Song from Alicia Keys' fifth studio album which was a commercial hit with over 4 million paid downloads in the U.S.: 3 wds. |
| 43% | HANDYMAN | 8 | Guy to see "if your broken heart needs repair," in a song |
| 42% | GIRLONFIRE | 10 | 2012 Alicia Keys song that shares its name with the nickname of Katniss in "The Hunger Games": 3 wds. |
| 41% | BARRACUDA | 9 | Fish with sharp teeth, or the title of a Heart song |
| 40% | UNTO | 4 | "___ a broken heart": Dickinson |
| 40% | BARRACUDA | 9 | 1977 Heart song with a sharp-toothed title |
| 40% | HEAL | 4 | Mend a broken heart? |
| 40% | POOL | 4 | Game with a break |
| 39% | UNTO | 4 | "___ a broken heart" (Emily Dickinson poem) |
| 39% | MEND | 4 | Heal, like a broken heart |
| 39% | MEND | 4 | Heal, as a broken heart |
| 39% | ACHE | 4 | "Pain" from a broken heart |
| 39% | HUMPTYDUMPTY | 12 | *Rhyme with a broken ovoid |
| 39% | ROCKABYEBABY | 12 | *Rhyme with a broken bough |
| 39% | JACKANDJILL | 11 | *Rhyme with a broken crown |
| 39% | GANESH | 6 | God with a broken tusk |
| 39% | BABYBEAR | 8 | Character with a broken chair |
| 39% | TONAL | 5 | With a key |
| 39% | BOO | 3 | "My ___" (Usher and Alicia Keys song) |
| 39% | FIRE | 4 | "Girl on ___" (2012 Alicia Keys song) |
| 38% | CPR | 3 | Help for a broken heart: Abbr. |
| 38% | CPR | 3 | How to mend a broken heart? |
| 38% | MEND | 4 | “How Can You ___ a Broken Heart” |
| 38% | ADLIB | 5 | Deal with a broken teleprompter, say |
| 38% | UNSAFECARAFE | 12 | Coffee vessel with a broken handle? |