| 100% | IGO | 3 | "___ to Pieces" (Peter and Gordon song) |
| 98% | IGOTO | 5 | Peter and Gordon song "___ Pieces" |
| 93% | IGO | 3 | Peter and Gordon hit "___ to Pieces" |
| 74% | NOBODYIKNOW | 11 | Peter and Gordon's answer to 23-Across |
| 60% | DUO | 3 | Peter and Gordon, e.g. |
| 59% | IGOTO | 5 | "___ Pieces" (Peter and Gordon hit) |
| 54% | ASHER | 5 | Peter of Peter and Gordon |
| 50% | SONS | 4 | Greg, Peter, and Bobby, to Mike Brady |
| 50% | STEPSONS | 8 | Greg, Peter, and Bobby, to Carol Brady |
| 50% | REND | 4 | Tear to bits and pieces |
| 50% | DEMOLISH | 8 | Reduce to bits and pieces |
| 48% | SONS | 4 | Greg, Peter, and Bobby, to Mike and Carol Brady |
| 47% | LOVESEY | 7 | Peter —, author of novels Rough Cider and Wobble to Death |
| 47% | BLOWININTHEWIND | 15 | 1960s weather song by Peter, Paul and Mary |
| 47% | NOTES | 5 | To the point and short pieces of writings |
| 47% | KNOWYOU | 7 | Getting to __, song from the King and I |
| 46% | CHELSOM | 7 | Peter —, director of films Serendipity, Hear My Song and Funny Bones |
| 46% | EBONY | 5 | Wood used to make chess pieces and pool cues |
| 46% | REND | 4 | Tear to bits and pieces (word hidden in "render") |
| 46% | GRRM | 4 | "A Song of Ice and Fire" author, to fans |
| 46% | ONREPEAT | 8 | Over and over, as a song one listens to |
| 46% | IRENECARA | 9 | She sang the title songs to Fame and Flashdance |
| 45% | NOEL | 4 | Seasonal song (and a hint to 11- and 22-Across) |
| 45% | TEA | 3 | "A drink with jam and bread," according to a song |
| 45% | BABE | 4 | Sonny to Cher, and vice versa, in song |
| 45% | PAN | 3 | Peter ___, the Neverland boy who stays forever young and refuses to grow up |
| 44% | SILVERANDGOLD | 13 | Seasonal Burl Ives song, and a hint to the circled letters |
| 44% | TOE | 3 | "Head to ___" (1987 hit song by Lisa Lisa and Cult Jam) |
| 44% | HAIR | 4 | Musical with such songs as "Aquarius" and "Easy to Be Hard" |
| 44% | WINGCHAIRS | 10 | Parlor pieces, and a hint to each set of circles |