| 100% | KEEPING | 7 | "__ The Faith" (Billy Joel song) |
| 100% | KEEPING | 7 | "___ the Faith" (Billy Joel song) |
| 80% | PRESSURE | 8 | 1982 Billy Joel song with the theme of stress |
| 77% | START | 5 | Billy Joel hit song "We Didn't ___ the Fire" |
| 77% | ALEXA | 5 | Billy Joel song, "The Downeaster —" |
| 69% | UPTOWN | 6 | The wealthy girl in Billy Joel song is from there |
| 68% | MYLIFE | 6 | Billy Joel song with the line "I don't want you to tell me it's time to come home" (2 wds.) |
| 68% | ITGOES | 6 | "And So __": Billy Joel song |
| 68% | ITGOES | 6 | "And So ___": Billy Joel song |
| 68% | PIANO | 5 | "___ Man" (classic Billy Joel song) |
| 68% | MAN | 3 | "Piano ___" (classic Billy Joel song) |
| 68% | PIANOMAN | 8 | Semi-autobiographical Billy Joel song |
| 66% | ALEXA | 5 | "The Downeaster ___" (Billy Joel song) |
| 66% | ALEXA | 5 | "The Downeaster '___'" (Billy Joel song) |
| 66% | ALLENTOWN | 9 | 1982 Billy Joel song |
| 66% | ARE | 3 | "Just the Way You __"; Billy Joel song |
| 65% | STATE | 5 | Billy Joel song, New York __ of Mind |
| 65% | ALLENTOWN | 9 | 1982 Billy Joel song (PA) |
| 65% | THEFIRE | 7 | In the song, Billy Joel didn't start it |
| 63% | OUT | 3 | "Movin' ___" (jukebox musical featuring Billy Joel songs) |
| 62% | ONLY | 4 | "___ the Good Die Young" (1977 Billy Joel song) |
| 61% | DIE | 3 | Billy Joel's "Only the Good ___ Young" |
| 61% | ONLY | 4 | Billy Joel's "___ the Good Die Young" |
| 61% | ARE | 3 | Billy Joel’s “Just the Way You —” |
| 61% | GOOD | 4 | Billy Joel said Only the __ Die Young |
| 60% | PIANOMAN | 8 | 1973 Billy Joel song about a bar musician: 2 wds. |
| 60% | START | 5 | Billy Joel's "We Didn't ___ the Fire" |
| 60% | START | 5 | Billy Joel’s “We Didn’t ___ the Fire” |
| 59% | LONGEST | 7 | Billy Joel's doo-wap hit, "For the __ time" |
| 59% | IGOTOEXTREMES | 13 | 1990 Billy Joel hit song: 4 wds. |