| 100% | CLEADUVALL | 10 | "But I'm a Cheerleader" star |
| 78% | CLEADUVALL | 10 | "But I'm a Cheerleader" actress |
| 74% | NATASHA | 7 | Lyonne who starred in “But I’m a Cheerleader” |
| 74% | CLEA | 4 | DuVall of "But I'm A Cheerleader" |
| 72% | CAMPY | 5 | Like the movie "But I'm a Cheerleader" |
| 66% | LYONNE | 6 | Natasha of “But I’m a Cheerleader” |
| 60% | CREEP | 5 | "... But I'm a ___, I'm a weirdo ..." (Radiohead lyrics) |
| 58% | GERMAN | 6 | I'm in Love With a __ Film Star, sang the Passions |
| 54% | ARTICLE | 7 | A but not I |
| 52% | KEY | 3 | A or E, but not I |
| 50% | LONGDIVISION | 12 | A r m y u n i t |
| 49% | FORE | 4 | "Hey, sorry that I'm not a great golfer, but watch out for that ball I just hit!" |
| 49% | KEYS | 4 | A and E, but not I, O or U |
| 49% | ALERS | 5 | A and O, but not E, I or U |
| 49% | NOTE | 4 | A or E, but not I, O or U |
| 49% | NAH | 3 | "Thanks, but I'm good" |
| 49% | NAH | 3 | “Thanks, but I'm set” |
| 49% | ONTV | 4 | "I'm not a doctor, but I play one ___" (old ad phrase): 2 wds. |
| 49% | MOSTPASTORS | 11 | "... but I've always thought ___ had a more fun job than I do" |
| 49% | AIM | 3 | I'm a moving target |
| 49% | AIM | 3 | I’m a moving target |
| 48% | CREEP | 5 | "....But I'm a ___ I'm a weirdo..." (Radiohead song) |
| 48% | ELEM | 4 | I, O or U, but not A or E: Abbr. |
| 48% | JOURNEYMAN | 10 | One who’s dependable but not a star |
| 48% | ILLBITE | 7 | "It's probably a trick, but tell me" |
| 48% | IVAN | 4 | "Nothing But a Man" star Dixon |
| 48% | EVITA | 5 | ''I'm only a radio star'' musical |
| 48% | NONEED | 6 | "Thanks, but I'm O.K." |
| 48% | NODEAL | 6 | "Sorry, but I'm not signing" |
| 48% | NOT | 3 | I'm ___ a robot (website test) |