| 100% | OHDAMN | 6 | "Did that really just happen?!" |
| 67% | WAITWHAT | 8 | "Did you really just say that?" |
| 61% | EYEROLL | 7 | Nonverbal "Did you really just say that?" reaction: 2 wds. |
| 58% | DID | 3 | "__ you really just say that?" |
| 55% | EARS | 4 | "I can't believe my ___!" ("Did you really just say that?") |
| 55% | PREVENTABLE | 11 | Like something that really shouldn't have happened |
| 55% | TRUELIFE | 8 | "So here's a thing that really happened . . ." |
| 52% | ASIF | 4 | "Oh, sure, that could really happen!" |
| 52% | ILETA | 5 | "How did ___ thing like that happen?" |
| 52% | OHSNAP | 6 | "He did not just say that!" |
| 52% | OHSNAP | 6 | “You did not just say that!” |
| 52% | WOW | 3 | "You just did me like that?!?!?!?!" |
| 52% | IFAT | 4 | "___ all that does happen...": 2 wds |
| 52% | TRUTHER | 7 | Conspiracy theorist who questions whether things that really happened really happened |
| 52% | NOWAY | 5 | "There's ___ that really happened!" ("Don't believe it!"): 2 wds. |
| 51% | ASIF | 4 | "Like that would really happen!": 2 wds. |
| 51% | NOGO | 4 | Something that just isn't gonna happen |
| 51% | PLACEBO | 7 | Pill that doesn't really do anything |
| 50% | ITWAS | 5 | "That really happened!" |
| 49% | OLE | 3 | "What you did with that bull was just amazing!" |
| 48% | ETTU | 4 | "You're really gonna do me like that too, amicus?" |
| 48% | LARKS | 5 | Birds that do things just for the fun of it? |
| 48% | ITSASIN | 7 | "That just shouldn't happen" |
| 47% | DID | 3 | “. . . ___ that just happen?” |
| 46% | SEEM | 4 | "It would ___ that Matthew is not really capable of doing anything properly!" |
| 46% | STIR | 4 | What to do to paint that's in a just-opened can |
| 46% | RAREMEAT | 8 | Something that's just not done at the dinner table? |
| 46% | OHSNAP | 6 | "Did you just see that?!" |
| 45% | ISHOULD | 7 | ''Really ought to do that . . .'' |
| 45% | SHORTERMEMORY | 13 | Recollection of something that just happened, concisely? |