| 100% | ADAGE | 5 | "Don't judge a book by its cover," for one |
| 88% | ADAGE | 5 | "Don't judge a book by its cover," for instance |
| 83% | CLOTHESMAKETHEMAN | 17 | Don't judge a book by its cover, but also... |
| 77% | SAW | 3 | "Don't judge a book by its cover," e.g. |
| 75% | ADAGE | 5 | "Don't judge a book by its cover" or "Pride cometh before a fall" |
| 72% | COVER | 5 | Don't judge a book by it |
| 71% | CLOTHESMAKETHEMAN | 17 | "You can't judge a book by its cover, but ..." |
| 68% | STEREOTYPED | 11 | Judged a book by its cover |
| 67% | COVER | 5 | "Don't judge a book by its ___" |
| 67% | COVER | 5 | * "Don't judge a book by its ___" |
| 66% | COVER | 5 | (3/5) "Don't judge a book by its ___" |
| 65% | BLURBS | 6 | They might help you judge a book by its cover |
| 65% | ITS | 3 | "Don't judge a book by ___ cover" |
| 65% | ITS | 3 | "Don't judge a book by __ cover" |
| 65% | ITS | 3 | “Don’t judge a book by ___ cover” |
| 61% | ITSCOVER | 8 | Don't judge a book by this |
| 58% | ITS | 3 | "You can't judge a book by ___ cover" |
| 58% | ITS | 3 | "You can't judge a book by __ cover" |
| 45% | ABOOK | 5 | “Don’t judge ___ by its cover” |
| 41% | BEERKOOZIE | 10 | Covering for a cold one |
| 40% | TRAP | 4 | "It's a ___, don't fall for it" |
| 39% | SWEARJAR | 8 | It's for those who don't give a darn |
| 39% | SLIPCASE | 8 | Close-fitting protective covering for a book |
| 38% | ATBAT | 5 | You don't get credit for this if you're hit by a pitch |
| 38% | ABOOK | 5 | You shouldn't judge it by its cover |
| 38% | ABOOK | 5 | "You can't judge ___ by its cover" |
| 38% | EMBOSSED | 8 | Raised letters on a book cover, for example |
| 38% | NONSENSE | 8 | "Don't believe it for a second" |
| 38% | KNEE | 4 | It's covered by a cap |
| 38% | RECORD | 6 | It's covered by a sleeve |