| 100% | SPELLITOUTFORME | 15 | "Explain like I'm 5 years old" |
| 44% | THAN | 4 | "I'm more nervous ___ my five year old." |
| 43% | NINTH | 5 | Like I Samuel among the books of the Old Testament |
| 40% | SIMILAR | 7 | Like I'm surrounded by terrible liars |
| 40% | DOI | 3 | "___ look like I'm joking?" |
| 39% | COY | 3 | Like one saying "Who, little old me?" |
| 39% | HUMORME | 7 | "Just act like I'm right..." |
| 39% | PARROTS | 7 | Birds that might accurately say “I’m fifty years old” |
| 38% | PHENOM | 6 | Like a 13 year old at Harvard |
| 38% | ONCE | 4 | "___ I was seven years old my momma told me..." |
| 38% | ELMO | 4 | Muppet who's always 3.5 years old |
| 37% | SHOHEIOHTANI | 12 | Los Angeles Dodger pitcher/slugger who turned 30 years old on July 5, 2024 (2 wds.) |
| 36% | WHOSWE | 6 | "You're talking like I'm actually on your side" |
| 36% | INA | 3 | "I feel like I'm ___ movie!": 2 wds. |
| 36% | ATA | 3 | "I feel like I'm ___ crossroads": 2 wds. |
| 36% | MINSTREL | 8 | I'm a medieval entertainer, like a singer |
| 35% | ASIDO | 5 | Like me |
| 35% | RUSSIANHOME | 11 | Like a Muscovite at 5 p.m.? |
| 35% | CLONED | 6 | Like the I.B.M. PC, often |
| 34% | SPRING | 6 | I'm the time of year for cleaning and picnics |
| 34% | SENIOR | 6 | Like I, to II |
| 34% | ROMAN | 5 | Like I, for one? |
| 34% | NASA | 4 | Ariana Grande hit with the lyric "It's like I'm the universe" |
| 33% | HUGS | 4 | "Hi, everyone! I'm Olaf, and I like warm ___" |
| 33% | EARLY | 5 | Like 5:00 or 6:00 a.m., say |
| 33% | NEHI | 4 | Pop that's over 80 years old |
| 33% | OREO | 4 | Cookie that's over 100 years old |
| 33% | TEENAGER | 8 | Person between 12 and 20 years old |
| 33% | ANTIQUES | 8 | Furniture pieces more than 100 years old |
| 33% | TEG | 3 | A sheep that's two years old |