| 100% | AMESS | 5 | "I'm ___" (Ed Sheeran song) |
| 86% | ALLOFTHESTARS | 13 | Ed Sheeran song |
| 83% | BAD | 3 | "___ Habits" (2021 Ed Sheeran song) |
| 82% | HAPPIER | 7 | 2017 Ed Sheeran song |
| 81% | ISEEFIRE | 8 | Ed Sheeran song on The Hobbit soundtrack |
| 79% | PUT | 3 | "___ It All on Me" (2019 Ed Sheeran song) |
| 78% | CASTLE | 6 | Ed Sheeran song about his youth: "__ on the Hill" |
| 78% | MULLIGAN | 8 | Nancy __, Ed Sheeran song about his grandparents |
| 78% | SHAPE | 5 | "___ of You" (Grammy-winning Ed Sheeran song) |
| 77% | AMESS | 5 | Ed Sheeran's "I'm ___" |
| 75% | CELESTIAL | 9 | Ed Sheeran and Pokémon song released 2022 |
| 74% | OFTHEBORDER | 11 | *Bilingual Ed Sheeran song featuring Camila Cabello and Cardi B |
| 71% | LEGOHOUSE | 9 | Ed Sheeran's song about a colorful toy brick home |
| 71% | THEHILL | 7 | Castle On __; Ed Sheeran hit song from 2017 |
| 70% | SHAPEOFYOU | 10 | 2017 Ed Sheeran song that sold 41.5 million digital copies: 3 wds. |
| 69% | SHAPE | 5 | "___ Of You" (Ed Sheeran song) |
| 69% | YOU | 3 | "Shape of ___" (Ed Sheeran song) |
| 68% | KISS | 4 | "___ Me," song by Ed Sheeran whose title is also "X" on a romantic card |
| 67% | ISEE | 4 | "___ Fire" (Ed Sheeran song) |
| 67% | SEA | 3 | "Tenerife ___" (Ed Sheeran song) |
| 66% | OVERTHERE | 9 | George M. Cohan W.W. I song |
| 64% | SHAPEOFYOU | 10 | 2017 Ed Sheeran song that was the 27th ever to debut atop the Billboard Hot 100: 3 wds. |
| 63% | YEBBA | 5 | One-named singer featured on Ed Sheeran's hit single "Best Part of Me" |
| 60% | MAYBE | 5 | "___ I'm Amazed" (Paul McCartney song) |
| 59% | YES | 3 | "___, I'm ready" (1965 Barbara Mason song) |
| 58% | ENDGAME | 7 | Taylor Swift song featuring Ed Sheeran and Future with the lyrics "I wanna be your first string / I wanna be your A-Team" (2 wds.) |
| 58% | PERFECT | 7 | Song by Ed Sheeran from his third studio album whose video starred Zoey Deutch |
| 57% | KOCH | 4 | Ed who asked "How'm I doin'?" |
| 57% | HILL | 4 | "Castle on the ___" (Ed Sheeran Top 10 song) |
| 56% | SIGNED | 6 | "___, Sealed, Delivered, I'm Yours" (Stevie Wonder song) |