| 100% | ALLSET | 6 | "I'm good when you are!" |
| 66% | HEART | 5 | "I'm a pumping organ that might beat faster when you're excited or scared. Who am I?" |
| 65% | NOT | 3 | "Who Are You When I'm ___ Looking" (Blake Shelton song) |
| 61% | MISS | 4 | 'When you are away, I ___ you so much' |
| 59% | ANTI | 4 | When you are against something |
| 57% | ONTAP | 5 | Ready when you are |
| 57% | ALLSET | 6 | "Ready when you are!" |
| 57% | IMSET | 5 | "Ready when you are!" |
| 57% | IMALLSET | 8 | "Ready when you are!" |
| 57% | IMALLSET | 8 | "Ready when you are" |
| 56% | ALAD | 4 | When I was ___ ("H.M.S. Pinafore" song) |
| 56% | IGO | 3 | "Will you miss me when ___?": 2 wds. |
| 56% | LETS | 4 | "I'm game if you are!" |
| 56% | DEC | 3 | Month when all retail stores play "All I Want for Christmas Is You," for short |
| 55% | HOME | 4 | "___ is wherever I'm with you" |
| 55% | ARE | 3 | "I'm ready when you ___" |
| 55% | BAD | 3 | "When I'm good, I'm very good. But when I'm ___, I'm better," iconic line by Mae West that was referenced in a Chumbawamba song |
| 55% | PEG | 3 | Steely Dan song with the lyrics "And when you smile for the camera / I know I'll love you better" |
| 55% | FREETIME | 8 | When you are not busy, you have lots of __ |
| 55% | SOLE | 4 | Touches the floor when you are barefoot |
| 55% | FRESHAIR | 8 | Breathe this in when you are outdoors |
| 55% | SEE | 3 | "When will I __ you again?" Three Degree song |
| 55% | HELLO | 5 | 48-Down song with the line "But when I call, you never seem to be home" |
| 54% | NOBODY | 6 | I'm __. Who are you? Then there's a pair of us |
| 54% | DILEMMA | 7 | Situation when you are split between two choices |
| 54% | EYE | 3 | "Keep an ___ on that while I'm away, will you?" |
| 54% | RAKINGMYMOUNDS | 14 | "The best part of the job, of course, is when I'm out on the street ___" |
| 54% | ETA | 3 | When you'll be there, briefly |
| 53% | REST | 4 | "When you're sick, ___ is best" (advice from "Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood") |
| 53% | HUH | 3 | "Come again?" (expression when you are not following something) |