| 100% | OWN | 3 | "I'm My ___ Grandpaw" (1948 novelty hit) |
| 50% | OUCH | 4 | "Gah! I hit my funny bone!" |
| 46% | ONYOU | 5 | I'm keeping my eye ___! |
| 46% | TIL | 3 | "___ I Can Make It on My Own" (Tammy Wynette #1 hit) |
| 45% | SEXY | 4 | "Da Ya Think I'm _____?" (1979 hit) |
| 44% | CHAPPELL | 8 | I M —, Australia Test cricketer who hit 165 against West Indies at Melbourne in 1968 |
| 44% | DAILEY | 6 | Dan ___, 1948 Best Actor nominee for "When My Baby Smiles at Me" |
| 44% | OHOH | 4 | "I'm raising my hand! Pick me!" |
| 43% | LOLA | 4 | Hit song with the line "When she squeezed me tight she nearly broke my spine" |
| 43% | STANDING | 8 | I'm Still __, 1983 hit single for Elton John |
| 42% | DONTSCARE | 9 | "Ooh, I'm shaking in my boots!" |
| 42% | YES | 3 | "___, I'm Ready" (1965 Barbara Mason hit) |
| 42% | CECILIA | 7 | 1970 hit with the lyric "I'm down on my knees, / I'm begging you please to come home" |
| 42% | HAT | 3 | "If I'm wrong, I'll eat my ___!" |
| 41% | THIS | 4 | "___ Is Why I'm Hot," 2007 #1 hit |
| 41% | SEXY | 4 | "Da Ya Think I'm ___?" (Rod Stewart hit) |
| 41% | JADA | 4 | Novelty hit of 1919 |
| 41% | CLOSEUP | 7 | Mr. DeMille, I'm ready for my __, Sunset Boulevard |
| 40% | HUSH | 4 | Deep Purple hit song with the lyric "I thought I heard her / calling my name now" |
| 40% | OVER | 4 | "I think I'm in ___ my head" |
| 40% | LIVINONAPRAYER | 14 | 1986 Bon Jovi hit with the lyric "Take my hand, we'll make it, I swear" |
| 40% | TBH | 3 | "If I'm truly expressing my opinion," in texting shorthand |
| 40% | HANGIN | 6 | "___ there, I'm on my way!" ("Hold on"): 2 wds. |
| 39% | NOCANDO | 7 | "Outta my hands, I'm afraid" |
| 39% | OWN | 3 | "I'm my ___ worst enemy" |
| 39% | VENICE | 6 | I'm a city in Italy and my nickname is "The Floating City" |
| 39% | ROME | 4 | I'm a city in Italy and my nickname is "The Eternal City" |
| 39% | DUBLIN | 6 | I'm a city in Ireland and my nickname is "The Fair City" |
| 39% | UGANDA | 6 | I'm an African country with a grey crowned crane on my flag |
| 39% | PEIS | 4 | I. M. and Mario |