| 100% | ABOAT | 5 | "I'm on ___" (Lonely Island song) |
| 88% | ABOAT | 5 | "I'm on ___" (hit parody song for the Lonely Island) |
| 88% | ABOAT | 5 | "I'm on ___" (The Lonely Island song with the lyric "I got my swim trunks, and my flippie-floppies") |
| 87% | BOAT | 4 | Lonely Island "I'm on a ___" |
| 85% | ONA | 3 | "I'm ___ Boat" (Lonely Island song) |
| 75% | SEX | 3 | "I Just Had ___" (The Lonely Island song) |
| 73% | ONA | 3 | "I'm ___ Boat" (song by the Lonely Island): 2 wds. |
| 66% | ONA | 3 | "I'm ___ Boat" (2009 Lonely Island hit) |
| 64% | SOS | 3 | "I'm stranded on an island and all I have are rocks!" |
| 63% | TAKE | 4 | "___ a Chance on Me" (ABBA song) |
| 63% | LEAN | 4 | "___ on Me" (Bill Withers song) |
| 62% | TREE | 4 | Lonely growth on a cartoon desert island |
| 61% | RAIN | 4 | "___ On Me," song by Lady Gaga |
| 61% | FIJI | 4 | I'm an island country in the South Pacific Ocean with a white dove and lion on my flag |
| 60% | AURALEE | 7 | Song on which "Love Me Tender" is based |
| 60% | AURALEE | 7 | Song that "Love Me Tender" is based on |
| 60% | TAKE | 4 | "___ On Me" (#1 song by 49-Down) |
| 59% | LAY | 3 | ABBA song "___ All Your Love on Me" |
| 59% | LAY | 3 | "___ Your Hands on Me" (Bon Jovi song) |
| 59% | OVERTHERE | 9 | George M. Cohan W.W. I song |
| 58% | LAYLA | 5 | Song title character who's "got me on my knees" |
| 58% | POUR | 4 | "___ Some Sugar on Me," song by Def Leppard |
| 57% | MALE | 4 | M, on certain forms ... also, when pronounced differently, the island capital of Maldives |
| 57% | SHOW | 4 | "___ Me the Meaning of Being Lonely," song by Backstreet Boys |
| 57% | TPAIN | 5 | R&B singer featured on the Lonely Island's "I'm on a Boat": Hyph. |
| 57% | AHA | 3 | Band with the 1985 song "Take On Me": Hyph. |
| 57% | GOTA | 4 | "You've Really ___ Hold on Me" (Smokey Robinson song) |
| 57% | SUGAR | 5 | Pour Some __ on Me; Def Leppard song from 1987 |
| 57% | IMONA | 5 | "___ Boat" (Lonely Island song featuring T-Pain) |
| 56% | DUET | 4 | Song such as Lady Gaga and Ariana Grande's "Rain on Me" |