| 100% | NEEDA | 5 | "I ___ Lover" (1979 John Cougar hit) |
| 63% | DIANE | 5 | "Jack & ___" (1982 John Cougar hit) |
| 61% | SOGOOD | 6 | "Hurts ___" (1982 John Cougar hit): 2 wds. |
| 59% | DIANE | 5 | Title girl in a 1982 #1 John Cougar hit |
| 58% | SHOCKINGPINKHOUSES | 18 | John Cougar Mellencamp hit sung by electric eels? |
| 57% | SADEYES | 7 | 1979 Robert John hit |
| 57% | SADEYES | 7 | 1979 Robert John hit that repeats "I don't wanna see you cry" |
| 57% | DIANE | 5 | John Cougar's No. 1 hit of 1982, "Jack & ___" |
| 55% | DIANE | 5 | Title girl in a John Cougar #1 hit |
| 55% | SADEYES | 7 | 1979 #1 hit for Robert John |
| 52% | STANDING | 8 | I'm Still __, 1983 hit single for Elton John |
| 52% | LEGEND | 6 | John who had a hit with All Of Me |
| 52% | ALL | 3 | "___ of Me" (#1 hit for John Legend) |
| 50% | LEGEND | 6 | Famous singer John ___ with the hit 'All of me' |
| 49% | ELO | 3 | Grp. with the 1979 hit "Don't Bring Me Down" |
| 47% | TINYDANCER | 10 | Elton John hit with the misheard lyric "Hold me closer, Tony Danza" |
| 47% | ELO | 3 | Band with the 1979 hit "Don't Bring Me Down," for short |
| 46% | ALL | 3 | "___ of Me," John Legend hit |
| 46% | CHEAPTRICK | 10 | Band with the 1979 hit "I Want You to Want Me": 2 wds. |
| 46% | RODSTEWART | 10 | British rocker with the 1979 #1 hit "Da Ya Think I'm Sexy?" |
| 45% | TINYDANCER | 10 | Elton John hit with the misheard lyric "Hold me closer, Tony Danza" |
| 44% | STILL | 5 | "I'm ___ Standing" (1983 Elton John hit) |
| 43% | ALL | 3 | "___ of Me" (John Legend hit) |
| 42% | USA | 3 | "R.O.C.K. in the ___" (John Cougar Mellencamp hit) |
| 42% | NOW | 3 | "Love Me ___" (John Legend hit song) |
| 42% | ALL | 3 | "___ of Me" (John Legend hit song) |
| 41% | NOW | 3 | "Love Me ___" (2016 John Legend hit song) |
| 41% | ROADS | 5 | "Take Me Home, Country __": John Denver hit |
| 40% | ALIEN | 5 | 1979 sci-fi hit |
| 40% | WOMAN | 5 | John Lennon hit |