| 100% | SAID | 4 | "I Am...I __"; Neil Diamond song |
| 91% | ISAID | 5 | "I Am...__"; Neil Diamond song |
| 86% | SHILO | 5 | Neil Diamond song with the lyrics, "When I was young / I used to call your name / When no one else would come" |
| 86% | SHILO | 5 | Neil Diamond song with the lyrics "When I was young / I used to call your name / When no one else would come" |
| 69% | IAMISAID | 8 | Neil Diamond song |
| 69% | SEPTEMBERMORN | 13 | Neil Diamond song |
| 69% | CRACKLINROSIE | 13 | Neil Diamond song |
| 69% | SWEETCAROLINE | 13 | Neil Diamond song |
| 68% | WINE | 4 | "Red, Red ___," song by UB40 and Neil Diamond which may be their preferred drink order |
| 64% | IAMI | 4 | “___ Said” (1971 Neil Diamond song) |
| 63% | SEPTEMBERMORN | 13 | "Timely" Neil Diamond song (2 wds.) |
| 62% | WHO | 3 | "___ I Am" (2024 Shawn Mendes song) |
| 62% | ITS | 3 | "___ Gonna Be Me" (NSYNC song) |
| 61% | DESIREE | 7 | Title woman of a 1977 Neil Diamond song |
| 61% | CHERRYCHERRY | 12 | Neil Diamond hit song (2 wds.) |
| 61% | SAID | 4 | "I AmÉI __"; Neil Diamond hit |
| 61% | BOY | 3 | "If I Were a ___" (Beyoncé song) |
| 61% | GONNA | 5 | "It's ___ Be Me" (*NSYNC song) |
| 61% | BOY | 3 | "If I Were a ___" (Beyonce song) |
| 60% | REMEMBER | 8 | Song by Sarah McLachlan: I Will __ You |
| 60% | MAN | 3 | "When I Was Your ___" (Bruno Mars song) |
| 60% | HERE | 4 | "___ I Am," song by Bryan Adams |
| 60% | ABOY | 4 | "If I Were —" (Beyoncé song) |
| 59% | SWEETCAROLINE | 13 | Neil Diamond song inspired by John F. Kennedy's daughter (2 wds.) |
| 59% | CAROLINE | 8 | Sweet __, US famous song, Neil Diamond |
| 59% | MEANT | 5 | "You Were ___ for Me" (Jewel song) |
| 59% | BABYONEMORETIME | 15 | "My loneliness is killing me . . ." song |
| 58% | REDREDWINE | 10 | 1967 Neil Diamond song title line preceding "Go to my head" |
| 58% | DESIREE | 7 | Title girl who "made it right" in a Neil Diamond song |
| 58% | DESIREE | 7 | "Girl almost twice my age" in a 1977 Neil Diamond song |