| 100% | SHOT | 4 | "I am not throwing away my ___" ("Hamilton" refrain) |
| 65% | AWAY | 4 | "I am not throwing ___ my shot" (line from "Hamilton") |
| 60% | IAM | 3 | "___ not throwing away my shot" ("Hamilton" lyric): 2 wds. |
| 59% | MYSHOT | 6 | Alexander Hamilton sings I'm not throwing away __ |
| 46% | INDIAARIE | 9 | "I Am Not My Hair" singer |
| 46% | PUN | 3 | "I threw away my golf shoes when I got a hole in one," e.g. |
| 45% | ARIE | 4 | "I Am Not My Hair" singer India.___ |
| 45% | INDIA | 5 | "I Am Not My Hair" singer ___.Arie |
| 45% | ARIE | 4 | "I Am Not My Hair" singer-songwriter India.___ |
| 44% | KEEP | 4 | Not throw away |
| 44% | REUSABLE | 8 | Not meant to be thrown away |
| 43% | JAMES | 5 | My code number is 007 and I like my martini shaken not stirred |
| 43% | REUSED | 6 | Not thrown away, say |
| 43% | NIMOY | 5 | I Am Not Spock author |
| 42% | WARREN | 6 | I am the CEO of Berkshire Hathaway and have pledged to give away 99% of my fortune to philanthropic causes |
| 41% | IHOPE | 5 | "___ I am not bothering you": 2 wds. |
| 40% | COIN | 4 | Something to toss but not throw away |
| 40% | AIMLESS | 7 | Oddly, I am not quite so haphazard |
| 39% | ALAS | 4 | "__, I am not coop'd here for defence!": Shak. |
| 39% | IAGO | 4 | "I am not what I am" speaker |
| 39% | OHARA | 5 | “Why I Am Not a Painter” poet Frank |
| 39% | ILOST | 5 | "Victory was not mine" |
| 39% | PAULSEN | 7 | "If elected I will not serve" candidate of 1968 |
| 39% | LITTLE | 6 | "___ Women," book by Louisa May Alcott which features the line "I am not afraid of storms, for I am learning how to sail my ship" |
| 38% | SIC | 3 | This is not my typo |
| 38% | SIC | 3 | [This is not my error] |
| 38% | DONTBLAMEME | 11 | "That was NOT my fault" |
| 38% | AREA | 4 | "This is not my ___ of expertise." |
| 37% | DALI | 4 | "I am not strange. I am just not normal" artist |
| 37% | PEA | 3 | "A seed with three letters in my name. Take away two and I still sound the same. What am I?" |