| 100% | THERE | 5 | "I guess you had to be ___" |
| 72% | HAD | 3 | "I guess you ___ to be there" |
| 72% | HAD | 3 | "I guess you ___ to be there!" |
| 70% | ANTE | 4 | You have to be upfront with it |
| 70% | ANTE | 4 | You have to be upfront about this |
| 68% | BEE | 3 | You have to be letter-perfect to win one |
| 68% | GOT | 3 | "You have ___ to be kidding me!" |
| 65% | COMEON | 6 | "You have got to be kidding me!" |
| 65% | KAHN | 4 | "It Had to Be You" lyricist |
| 65% | ASK | 3 | "All you had to do was ___" |
| 64% | FACEPALM | 8 | "You have got to be kidding me!" gesture |
| 64% | ISHAM | 5 | "It Had to Be You" composer ___ Jones |
| 64% | KAHN | 4 | "It Had to Be You" lyricist Gus |
| 64% | ISHAM | 5 | "It Had to Be You" composer Jones |
| 64% | OMG | 3 | "You have *got* to be kidding me" |
| 64% | HARRY | 5 | "It Had to Be You" crooner Connick Jr. |
| 63% | OHGOD | 5 | “You have got to be kidding me” |
| 63% | OHCOMEON | 8 | “You have got to be kidding me!” |
| 63% | AGELIMIT | 8 | Restriction on how old you have to be to do something: 2 wds. |
| 63% | ANNIEHALL | 9 | Title character who sings "It Had to Be You" |
| 62% | DREAM | 5 | "Whenever I want you, all I have to do" is this, in an Everly Brothers hit |
| 62% | THERE | 5 | "You had to be ___" |
| 62% | SECRET | 6 | "If you have me, you want to share me. If you share me, you have lost me. What am I?" |
| 61% | AMERICANDREAM | 13 | “It’s called the ___ ’cause you have to be asleep to believe it”: George Carlin |
| 61% | ESP | 3 | "Do you have ___?" ("That guess was uncanny!") |
| 60% | DIDNT | 5 | "You _____ Have to Be So Nice" |
| 60% | ALITTLEPATIENT | 14 | "You have to be ___," said the pediatrician |
| 59% | FACEPALM | 8 | Nonverbal equivalent of "You have got to be kidding me!" |
| 59% | MARLO | 5 | "Free to Be... You and Me" co-creator Thomas |
| 59% | WET | 3 | You and I have time to soak |