| 100% | SEX | 3 | "I Just Had ___" (The Lonely Island song) |
| 66% | ABOAT | 5 | "I'm on ___" (The Lonely Island song with the lyric "I got my swim trunks, and my flippie-floppies") |
| 59% | ONA | 3 | "I'm ___ Boat" (song by the Lonely Island): 2 wds. |
| 59% | NERVE | 5 | "If I Only Had the ___" (Cowardly Lion's song) |
| 57% | SHOW | 4 | "___ Me the Meaning of Being Lonely," song by Backstreet Boys |
| 55% | OOPSIDIDITAGAIN | 15 | Britney Spears song with the lyric "That is just so typically me" |
| 55% | BALIHAI | 7 | South Pacific song with the lyric "Here am I, your special island" |
| 55% | INC | 3 | "Monsters, ___," Pixar film with the song "If I Didn't Have You" |
| 54% | ABOAT | 5 | "I'm on ___" (hit parody song for the Lonely Island) |
| 54% | IMONABOAT | 9 | Grammy-nominated song by The Lonely Island: 4 wds. |
| 53% | SATIRIZES | 9 | Emulates the Lonely Island, say |
| 53% | IJUSTHADSEX | 11 | The Lonely Island hit featuring Akon: 4 wds. |
| 52% | CRY | 3 | Faith Hill song that begins, "If I had just one tear running down your cheek" |
| 52% | TPAIN | 5 | R&B singer featured on the Lonely Island's "I'm on a Boat": Hyph. |
| 52% | INVISIBLE | 9 | 52-Across song with the lyric "Then I could just watch you in your room" |
| 52% | JACKSPARROW | 11 | The Lonely Island hit featuring Michael Bolton: 2 wds. |
| 52% | FIZZLED | 7 | *I thought I had a good firework joke, but in the end, it just ___ out! (ended weakly) |
| 51% | ONLY | 4 | "__ the Lonely"; Orbison song |
| 51% | ONE | 3 | The loneliest number of song |
| 50% | HEAT | 4 | "___ Waves," 2020 song by Glass Animals that was featured in the TV series "Never Have I Ever" |
| 50% | ONLY | 4 | "___ the Lonely" (Roy Orbison song) |
| 50% | ONLY | 4 | "__ the Lonely"; Roy Orbison song |
| 50% | KEN | 3 | "I'm Just ___" ("Barbie" song performed at the 2024 Oscars) |
| 50% | RAEJEPSEN | 9 | Carly, singer who had The Loneliest Time in 2022 |
| 50% | ONLY | 4 | "___ the Lonely" (Roy Orbison hit song) |
| 49% | ONLY | 4 | "If I ___ Had a Brain" ("The Wizard of Oz" song) |
| 49% | TILLYOULOVEME | 13 | Reba McEntire song with the lyric "I guess I can wait if that's what I have to do" |
| 49% | HEARTOFGLASS | 12 | 1979 Blondie #1 song with the lyrics "Once I had a love and it was a gas" (3 wds.) |
| 48% | THEMAN | 6 | Taylor Swift song with the lyric "Every conquest I had made would make me more of a boss to you" |
| 48% | YODELER | 7 | The lonely goatherd, in a "Sound of Music" song |