| 100% | BAR | 3 | "I Love This ___" (Toby Keith song) |
| 94% | BAR | 3 | Toby Keith hit song "I Love This ___" |
| 64% | TOBY | 4 | "I Love This Bar" country singer ___ Keith |
| 60% | SOLO | 4 | "Red ___ Cup" (2011 Toby Keith song) |
| 59% | AGO | 3 | "Beers ___" (nostalgic Toby Keith song) |
| 57% | WHOOWHOOPIEPIE | 14 | "Suh-weet! I love this sandwich cookie!"? |
| 57% | THATSMYJAM | 10 | "I love this song!" … or a doubly apt description of 17-, 28- and 46-Across |
| 57% | APARADE | 7 | What I love, in song |
| 56% | BEER | 4 | Brewery beverage mentioned in many Toby Keith songs |
| 56% | THATSMYJAM | 10 | "I love this song!," and what might be said about 17-, 22-, 36-, and 48-Across? |
| 56% | CANT | 4 | "___ Buy Me Love" (Lennon-McCartney song) |
| 56% | AND | 3 | "__ I Love Her"; Beatles song |
| 55% | THATSMYJAM | 10 | “I love this song!” . . . or a hint to the starts of 17-, 27-, 39-, and 52-Across |
| 55% | LET | 3 | "___ Me Love You" (DJ Snake song) |
| 55% | AMERICANRIDE | 12 | Toby Keith song with the lyric "Look Ma, no hands" (2 wds.) |
| 55% | HER | 3 | "And I Love ___" (Beatles song) |
| 55% | HER | 3 | "And I Love ____" (Beatles song) |
| 55% | HER | 3 | "And I Love __"; Beatles song |
| 53% | ITLLBEFUN | 9 | "You're gonna love this, I promise!" |
| 53% | YOUS | 4 | "No More I Love ___" (Annie Lennox song) |
| 53% | HIM | 3 | “But Daddy I Love ___” (Taylor Swift song) |
| 52% | HER | 3 | "And I Love ___," hit song by The Beatles |
| 51% | ITSGREAT | 8 | "I love this!" |
| 50% | SWANEE | 6 | ''How I love ya'' river of song |
| 50% | DADDY | 5 | "But ___ I Love Him" (Taylor Swift song) |
| 49% | TENDER | 6 | Elvis Presley hit song Love Me __ |
| 49% | TENDER | 6 | 1956 Elvis Presley song: Love Me __ |
| 49% | ELSE | 4 | "Somewhere ___" (Toby Keith song) |
| 49% | LET | 3 | "___ Me Love You" (Mario song) |
| 49% | WHEE | 4 | "I love this roller coaster!" |