| 100% | EEN | 3 | "I should ___ die with pity...": Lear |
| 95% | EEN | 3 | "I should ___ die with pity": King Lear |
| 92% | EEN | 3 | "I should ___ die with pity, / To see another thus": King Lear |
| 75% | EEN | 3 | "I should ___ die with pity, / To see another thus": Shak. |
| 59% | ERE | 3 | "I shall see thee, ___ I die, look pale with love": "Much Ado About Nothing" |
| 49% | ANGER | 5 | "Touch me with noble ___": King Lear |
| 48% | ELENAFORBES | 11 | Crime writer whose 2007 debut novel was Die with Me |
| 46% | ROMEOMONTAGUE | 13 | "Thus with a kiss I die" speaker |
| 46% | ROMEO | 5 | "Thus with a kiss I die" hero |
| 45% | THE | 3 | With 8-Across, "Should I Stay or Should I Go" band |
| 45% | CABARET | 7 | Musical with the song "Why Should I Wake Up?" |
| 45% | ROMEO | 5 | Character who said "Thus with a kiss I die" |
| 45% | ACTV | 4 | When Romeo says, "Thus with a kiss I die" |
| 44% | ROMEO | 5 | His last words were "Thus with a kiss I die" |
| 44% | ROMEO | 5 | Whose last words are "Thus with a kiss I die" |
| 41% | PESTO | 5 | Possible answer to the question “What should I make with all this basil?” |
| 41% | APTTO | 5 | "I shall not find myself so ___ die": Antony |
| 40% | ORI | 3 | "..._____ shall die" |
| 40% | ORI | 3 | "... ___ shall die" |
| 38% | ORI | 3 | "...___ shall die" (1967 lyric) |
| 38% | CONKS | 5 | Dies, with "out" |
| 38% | MRT | 3 | Actor with the catchphrase "I pity the fool!" |
| 37% | EVER | 4 | "If ___ I should leave..." |
| 37% | ELSE | 4 | "Anything ___ I should know?" |
| 37% | BTW | 3 | "Oh, I should mention ..." |
| 37% | AIDA | 4 | She dies with Radames |
| 37% | MRT | 3 | Actor with the famous line "I pity the fool!" |
| 36% | FYI | 3 | "Thought I should share," briefly |
| 36% | SO | 2 | "And I should care ... why?" |
| 36% | OKSO | 4 | "And I should care because ...?" |