| 100% | HIM | 3 | "I Will Follow ___" (1963 #1 hit) |
| 76% | HIM | 3 | "I Will Follow ___" (1963 #1 song) |
| 71% | NSYNC | 5 | Boy band with the No. 1 hit "It's Gonna Be Me" |
| 71% | NSYNC | 5 | Pop group with the No. 1 hit "It's Gonna Be Me" |
| 68% | EFGH | 4 | I will follow it |
| 66% | FILL | 4 | I will follow fellow and pack |
| 65% | LIPID | 5 | I would follow edge of compound |
| 65% | EFGH | 4 | What I will follow |
| 64% | BEAR | 4 | "(Let Me Be Your) Teddy ___" (Elvis Presley #1 hit song) |
| 63% | KILL | 4 | Terminate king and I will follow |
| 63% | ONEFINEDAY | 10 | When "the arms I long for will open wide," in a 1963 top 5 hit |
| 62% | AITCH | 5 | I will often follow this |
| 61% | BOY | 3 | "If I Were a ___" (Beyonce hit) |
| 60% | LWAYSTOLEAVEYOURLOVER | 21 | 1976 #1 hit whose title follows the words "There must be ..." |
| 60% | NSYNC | 5 | *Group with the 2000 #1 hit "It's Gonna Be Me" |
| 60% | NSYNC | 5 | Boy band with the #1 hit "It's Gonna Be Me" |
| 60% | THIS | 4 | "___ Is Why I'm Hot," 2007 #1 hit |
| 60% | OUR | 3 | "___ Day Will Come" (1963 #1 hit) |
| 60% | ABOY | 4 | "If I Were —" (Beyonce hit) |
| 58% | SCRABBLE | 8 | Game in which I is 1 |
| 58% | FOURTOPS | 8 | R&B group with the #1 hit "Reach Out I'll Be There" |
| 58% | WHEN | 4 | "___ I Was Your Man" (2013 Bruno Mars hit) |
| 57% | SURE | 4 | "How Can I Be ___?" (Young Rascals hit) |
| 57% | GOTTA | 5 | "I've ___ Be Me" (1969 hit) |
| 57% | NSYNC | 5 | Boy band whose only #1 hit is "It's Gonna Be Me": 2 wds. |
| 56% | MAN | 3 | "When I Was Your ___" (2013 Bruno Mars hit) |
| 56% | SHED | 4 | "_____ Rather Be With Me" (1967 hit) |
| 56% | SHED | 4 | "___ Rather Be With Me" (1967 hit) |
| 56% | GONNA | 5 | "It's ___ Be Me" (NSYNC hit) |
| 56% | JAILHOUSEROCK | 13 | 1957 #1 Elvis hit whose B-side was "Treat Me Nice": 2 wds. |