| 100% | HAD | 3 | "If I ___ a nickel for every time ..." |
| 100% | HAD | 3 | "If I ___ a nickel for every time . . ." |
| 100% | HAD | 3 | "If I ___ a nickel for every time ... " |
| 84% | IHAD | 4 | "If ___ a nickel for every time ...": 2 wds. |
| 84% | IHAD | 4 | "If ___ a nickel for every time...": 2 wds. |
| 74% | HADA | 4 | "If I ___ nickel for every time ...": 2 wds. |
| 61% | IHAD | 4 | "If ___ a dollar for every time...": 2 wds. |
| 53% | IHAD | 4 | “If ___ a nickel for ...” |
| 52% | IMBUSY | 6 | "Not a good time for me" |
| 50% | BACK | 4 | "If I Could Turn ___ Time," song by Cher which is a powerful ballad about wishing for a way to undo mistakes |
| 49% | ANEW | 4 | Once more as if for the first time, a fresh go |
| 47% | ACTIVE | 6 | Type of lifestyle you have if you go for a walk every morning |
| 47% | HAD | 3 | If I ___ a Hammer |
| 47% | COFFEEOCLOCK | 12 | Time for a pick-me-up, humorously |
| 46% | GOREVIDAL | 9 | "Every time a friend succeeds, I die a little" |
| 46% | SAMSA | 5 | Kafka protagonist who wonders, “What if I went back to sleep for a while and forgot all this foolishness?” |
| 45% | TOTO | 4 | "Rosanna by ___ but every time it says rosanna i say banana and take a bite of a banana" (YouTube video) |
| 45% | ALARM | 5 | I'm a type of digital clock that gets you ready for classes on time. Who am I? |
| 45% | YOUDONTNEEDTOKNOWTHIS | 21 | "If I could digress for a moment …" |
| 45% | HADA | 4 | "If I ___ penny for every ..." |
| 45% | IMDB | 4 | App I open literally every time I watch a film |
| 44% | PERCH | 5 | For every church has a seat |
| 44% | ONCE | 4 | "If I've told you ___, I've told you a thousand times ..." |
| 44% | ONCE | 4 | "If I've said it ___, I've said it a thousand times ..." |
| 44% | ILSA | 4 | Character who says “Kiss me as if it were the last time” to Rick, in a 1942 film |
| 43% | AWHILE | 6 | For a time |
| 42% | GIVE | 4 | "___ Me a Break" (title for this puzzle?) |
| 42% | NOON | 4 | Time for a whistle |
| 42% | INYEARS | 7 | For a long time |
| 42% | SPRING | 6 | Time for a break |