| 100% | IDVE | 4 | "If I Knew You Were Comin' ___ Baked a Cake" (popular song) |
| 91% | IDVE | 4 | "If I Knew You Were Comin' ___ Baked a Cake" (Eileen Barton song) |
| 84% | IDVE | 4 | "If I Knew You Were Comin' ___ Baked a Cake" |
| 47% | BAKEDACAKE | 10 | What I'd've done "if I knew you were comin' " |
| 43% | TROUBLE | 7 | "I Knew You Were ___," hit Taylor Swift song |
| 41% | OVEN | 4 | Appliance needed if you want to bake a cake |
| 40% | YOUDBESETONSTUNNING | 19 | "I know it's not my business, but if you were a laser ..." |
| 40% | MOMMY | 5 | I am a character from a popular Christmas song who kisses Santa Claus |
| 40% | HEARMEOUT | 9 | "I know you think this is a ludicrous idea, but ..." |
| 40% | BOY | 3 | "If I Were a ___" (Beyoncé song) |
| 40% | BOY | 3 | "If I Were a ___" (Beyonce song) |
| 39% | SHOUT | 5 | What "you know you make me wanna" do, in a classic R&B song |
| 37% | ARE | 3 | "I know you ___ but what am I?" |
| 37% | ARE | 3 | "I know you ___, but what am I?" |
| 37% | HED | 3 | "I knew a man Bojangles and ___ dance for you ..." (1968 song lyric) |
| 37% | RETORTED | 8 | Said “I know you are, but what am I?,” e.g. |
| 37% | EVEN | 4 | "You Don't ___ Know Who I Am" (Patty Loveless song) |
| 37% | IHATEMEN | 8 | "Kiss Me, Kate" song with the lyric "For husbands are a boring lot and only give you bother" |
| 36% | OVEN | 4 | Where a cake is baked |
| 36% | EVER | 4 | "If you're ___ in a jam, here I am" (first line of the classic song "Friendship") |
| 36% | PROPOSAL | 8 | "Will you marry me?" gesture that is a popular break-time sight in most stadium sports |
| 36% | AHA | 3 | "I knew you were bluffing!" |
| 36% | ONMYMIND | 8 | Like Georgia (if I were Ray Charles), or a song by Ellie Goulding |
| 36% | IRIS | 4 | Hit song for the Goo Goo Dolls with the repeated line "I just want you to know who I am" |
| 35% | RSVP | 4 | "Let me know if you're coming" |
| 35% | TAYLORSWIFT | 11 | "I Knew You Were Trouble" singer |
| 35% | WAITING | 7 | "I Knew You Were ___ For Me," 1987 romantic duet by Aretha Franklin and George Michael |
| 35% | BYNOW | 5 | "If You Don't Know Me ___" (Harold Melvin & the Blue Notes song) |
| 35% | BADIDEA | 7 | "Wouldn't do that if I were you" |
| 35% | SINNER | 6 | “Ah, if the Pope knew you were such a ___ / He’d be on his way”: Springsteen |