| 100% | AMI | 3 | "Is that what you think of me?" |
| 66% | IMHURT | 6 | "How could you think that of me?" |
| 62% | OHREALLY | 8 | “Is that what you’d have me believe?” |
| 61% | ITSANHONOR | 10 | "Grateful that you'd think of me!" |
| 58% | KIND | 4 | "What ___ of a fool do you think I am?" |
| 57% | ESP | 3 | Purported ability that could let you know what someone else is thinking: Abbr. |
| 56% | ESP | 3 | "Are you thinking what I'm thinking?" feeling |
| 56% | HADNT | 5 | "I ____ thought of that until you brought it up." |
| 56% | SOW | 3 | "You reap what you ___," fall-related idiom that means one will face the consequences of their actions |
| 55% | POSTHOCERGOPROPTERHOC | 21 | What's more, one of those friends won the lottery right after solving it — coincidence? I think not! |
| 55% | ELSE | 4 | "Can you think of anything ___ I need? |
| 55% | IDEA | 4 | What you may think of |
| 54% | FYI | 3 | "I think you should be aware of this ...": Abbr. |
| 54% | SEE | 3 | "That's what I was trying to tell you!" |
| 54% | REALORIGINAL | 12 | Sarcastic "Oh, like you thought of that yourself" |
| 54% | ESP | 3 | You thinking what I'm thinking? |
| 53% | CASABLANCA | 10 | 1942 film that ends with the line “Louis, I think this is the beginning of a beautiful friendship” |
| 53% | PUNS | 4 | Bits of wordplay that may make you groan... and what 10a, 24a, 27a, 14d, and 23d all are! |
| 53% | REP | 3 | What people think of you, for short |
| 53% | ARE | 3 | "___ you thinking what I'm thinking?" |
| 53% | OPINION | 7 | That's what you think |
| 53% | OPINION | 7 | That's what you think! |
| 53% | OUTAT | 5 | "What were you doing ___ that time of the night?": 2 wds. |
| 53% | HAL | 3 | Film character who says menacingly "I think you know what the problem is just as well as I do" |
| 53% | AJA | 3 | Album that begins "In the corner of my eye / I saw you in Rudy's / You were very high" |
| 52% | ARE | 3 | What you may have that I can't? |
| 52% | ARE | 3 | What you can take that I can't? |
| 52% | WHOME | 5 | "Wait, you think I did that?" |
| 52% | SURPRISED | 9 | "Is that what you expected?" |