| 100% | CLEAR | 5 | "It Came Upon a Midnight ___," 1997 Christmas episode from the TV series "Touched By An Angel" |
| 42% | LEXMAS | 6 | 2005 Christmas episode from the TV series "Smallville" |
| 40% | STREET | 6 | "Miracle on Third or Fourth ___," 1993 Christmas episode from the TV series "Frasier" |
| 38% | TALE | 4 | "Mike's Dream: A Christmas ___," 1993 Christmas episode from the TV series "Dr.Quinn, Medicine Woman" |
| 37% | KNOPE | 5 | "Citizen ___," Christmas episode from the fourth season of the TV series "Parks and Recreation" |
| 35% | TOGETHER | 8 | "___ for Christmas," 1962 Christmas episode from the TV series "The Lucy Show" |
| 35% | ANDY | 4 | ___ Bernard, salesman from the TV series "The Office" who won't miss an opportunity to break into a capella |
| 32% | DELLA | 5 | With 37-Across, "Touched by an Angel" actress who played a landlady on "Chico and the Man" |
| 32% | CLEAR | 5 | "It Came Upon a Midnight ___" |
| 32% | PARTY | 5 | "Christmas ___," holiday episode from the second season of the TV series "The Office" |
| 31% | KENNY | 5 | ___ McCormick, character from the TV series "South Park" who wears an orange parka |
| 31% | HARVEY | 6 | ___ Specter, fictional lawyer from the TV series "Suits" which is played by Gabriel Macht |
| 31% | PERRY | 5 | ___ Mason, fictional lawyer from the TV series of the same name played by Matthew Rhys |
| 31% | SAUL | 4 | ___ Goodman, fictional lawyer from the TV series "Breaking Bad" which is played by Bob Odenkirk |
| 31% | MABEL | 5 | ___ Pines, character from the TV series "Gravity Falls" who wears a variety of colorful sweaters |
| 30% | CARLTON | 7 | Chatty doorman from the TV series "Rhoda" who is heard through an intercom but never seen |
| 30% | FARGO | 5 | TV series based on a 1996 film by the Coen brothers |
| 30% | ERICA | 5 | Character from the TV series "BoJack Horseman" whose name is called out but never makes a single appearance |
| 30% | TUCKER | 6 | Cameron ___, music teacher from the TV series "Modern Family" who performs like a Broadway star in unusual places |
| 30% | SIMPSONS | 8 | "The ___," animated TV series by Matt Groening, with a crossover episode featuring "The X-Files" characters |
| 29% | CLEAR | 5 | "It Came Upon the Midnight ___" |
| 29% | BLESSED | 7 | Touched by an angel |
| 29% | OUT | 3 | Touched by an Angel? |
| 29% | RECAP | 5 | Set of clips from the previous episode of a TV show |
| 29% | UGLY | 4 | ___ Naked Guy, infamous neighbor from the TV series "Friends" who is mentioned in detail but never makes a single appearance |
| 29% | SIMPSONS | 8 | "The ___," animated TV series where a snowstorm in an episode ruins Bart's efforts to pass a test |
| 29% | REESE | 5 | Touched by an Angel star |
| 29% | ALF | 3 | TV series from the 80s with a friendly extraterrestrial creature playing the title character |
| 29% | ANGEL | 5 | "Touched by an ___" (1994-2003 TV series) |
| 29% | ANGEL | 5 | "Touched by an ___" (Roma Downey TV series) |