| 100% | AGO | 3 | "It seems like so long ___" |
| 74% | AGO | 3 | "It feels like so long ___" |
| 69% | BEEN | 4 | “___ Down So Long It Looks Like Up to Me” (Richard Fariña novel) |
| 65% | AEON | 4 | It seems like forever |
| 61% | ATOP | 4 | Like so over it? |
| 60% | AGO | 3 | "It seems like it happened ages ___" |
| 59% | ORNOT | 5 | "... but it seems like you hate the idea" |
| 59% | GUESSSO | 7 | "Sure seems like it" |
| 57% | FRAME | 5 | Make it seem like someone else is the baddie, say |
| 55% | SEP | 3 | Mo. that seems like it should be seventh |
| 55% | PAPERTHIN | 9 | Like motel walls, it often seems |
| 54% | ADDERS | 6 | Snakes whose name makes it seem like they'd be good at math? |
| 54% | ZETA | 4 | Greek letter that seems like it should be last |
| 54% | SCARCE | 6 | Like hens' teeth, so it's said |
| 53% | IVE | 3 | "___ been waiting for so long!" ("Is it my turn yet?") |
| 53% | PURE | 4 | Like the driven snow, so it's said |
| 52% | MAYAN | 5 | Like the calendar known for its Long Count |
| 52% | FLOSSING | 8 | Dance that won't help gums but seems like it might |
| 50% | ENDLESS | 7 | Like tedious meetings, it seems |
| 49% | LEGEND | 6 | Story so widely told, it's almost like history |
| 49% | IDEA | 4 | "It seemed like a good ___ at the time" |
| 49% | IDEA | 4 | "It seemed like a good ___ at the time!" |
| 49% | IDEA | 4 | ''It seemed like a good ___ at the time!'' |
| 49% | NOEL | 4 | Coward who said "I love criticism just so long as it's unqualified praise" |
| 49% | NOTFITFORTHEJOB | 15 | Like the start of four long answers, vis-à-vis its answer? |
| 48% | EVER | 4 | "Be it ___ so humble, there's no place like home" |
| 48% | TIES | 4 | They’re like kissing your sister, so it’s said |
| 48% | ABSTRACT | 8 | Artwork that's changed so it's no longer realistic |
| 48% | PEACOCK | 7 | Male bird that displays its long feathers like a fan |
| 48% | IDSAYSO | 7 | “Seems like it to me” |