| 100% | DREAMT | 6 | "Last night I ___ of San Pedro" ("La Isla Bonita" lyric) |
| 36% | DREAMT | 6 | “Last night I ___ I went to Manderley again” (opening line of “Rebecca”) |
| 35% | AWFUL | 5 | Like the shows "Here's Where I Belong" in '68 and "La Strada" in '69, both of which lasted one night on Broadway |
| 34% | ISLA | 4 | "This is where I long to be, la ___ bonita" (Madonna lyrics) |
| 33% | SULA | 4 | San Pedro ___, Honduras (anagram of "saul") |
| 32% | NYE | 3 | The last night of the year (initialism) |
| 31% | NYE | 3 | The last night of the year, for short |
| 31% | SYNE | 4 | Word sung on the last night of the year |
| 30% | EPODE | 5 | Last part of a Greek lyric poem |
| 30% | EBAY | 4 | Owner of Bill Me Later |
| 30% | CUBA | 4 | Isla de la Juventud is part of it |
| 30% | ELIZABETH | 9 | Last monarch of the House of Tudor: __ I |
| 30% | SETH | 4 | Meyers of late night |
| 29% | JOEL | 4 | Pedro Pascal's character on "The Last of Us" |
| 29% | BYDOGS | 6 | I found a fox, caught __ Hounds of Love lyrics |
| 29% | AMORE | 5 | Theme of la festa di San Valentino |
| 29% | TUDORS | 6 | Elizabeth I was the last of them |
| 29% | LENO | 4 | Jay of late night fame |
| 29% | SETH | 4 | Meyers of late night TV |
| 29% | ESPANA | 6 | Owner of las Islas Canarias |
| 29% | MALLORCA | 8 | One of las Islas Baleares |
| 29% | HAD | 3 | I ___ tea last night |
| 29% | ARONI | 5 | The last part of "the San Francisco Treat"? |
| 29% | SEEN | 4 | Cher "You Haven't ___ the Last of Me"") |
| 28% | SPEE | 4 | Last word in the name of a WW I German warship |
| 28% | COATES | 6 | Last name on the cover of Between the World and Me |
| 28% | SCUSE | 5 | ___ Me While I Kiss This Guy (book of misheard lyrics) |
| 28% | CCCLI | 5 | Last full year of St. Julius I's papacy |
| 28% | JONLOVITZ | 9 | *"Saturday Night Live" cast member of the late 1980s |
| 28% | LOWE | 4 | Rob of "About Last Night..." |