| 100% | SHARONA | 7 | "M-m-m-my" girl in a 1979 #1 hit |
| 82% | SHARONA | 7 | Title girl in a 1979 #1 hit |
| 81% | SHARONA | 7 | Title girl in a 1979 #1 hit song |
| 80% | SHARONA | 7 | "My" girl in a 1979 hit |
| 70% | SARA | 4 | Title girl in a 1979 Fleetwood Mac hit |
| 66% | SLOOPY | 6 | Title girl in a 1965 #1 hit |
| 64% | SHARONA | 7 | Title girl in a 1979 #1 song by the Knack |
| 63% | SUSIE | 5 | Girl in a #1 Everly Brothers hit |
| 61% | DIANE | 5 | Title girl in a 1982 #1 John Cougar hit |
| 61% | SHEILA | 6 | Girl with blue eyes and a ponytail, in a 1962 #1 hit |
| 61% | RHONDA | 6 | The "you" in "you caught my eye" in a 1965 #1 hit |
| 61% | DIANE | 5 | Title girl in a John Cougar #1 hit |
| 60% | RHONDA | 6 | Girl in a Beach Boys hit |
| 60% | SHEILA | 6 | "Her cheeks are rosy, she looks a little nosey" girl in a 1962 #1 hit |
| 58% | MARYLOU | 7 | Title girl in a Ricky Nelson hit |
| 58% | BETH | 4 | Title girl in a 1976 Kiss hit |
| 58% | DONNA | 5 | Title girl in a Ritchie Valens hit |
| 58% | RENEE | 5 | Title girl in a Left Banke hit |
| 58% | SARA | 4 | Title girl in a 1986 Starship hit |
| 58% | SUSAN | 5 | Title girl in a 1968 Buckinghams hit |
| 58% | ELENORE | 7 | Title girl in a 1968 Turtles hit |
| 58% | NADINE | 6 | Title girl in a Chuck Berry hit |
| 58% | SUE | 3 | "Runaround" girl in a 1961 Dion hit |
| 57% | BETH | 4 | Title girl in a 1976 Kiss hit song |
| 57% | YMCA | 4 | "A place you can go," in a 1979 #2 hit |
| 56% | NOLA | 4 | Title girl in a 1922 hit |
| 55% | JOANNA | 6 | Title girl in a 1983 Kool & the Gang hit |
| 55% | RADIOSTAR | 9 | Whom "video killed," in a 1979 hit |
| 55% | NANETTE | 7 | Title girl in a hit 1925 musical |
| 55% | SHEILA | 6 | "Blue eyes and a ponytail" girl in a 1962 hit |