| 100% | MASH | 4 | "Monster ___" (1962 song that's popular around Halloween) |
| 78% | MASH | 4 | "Monster ___" (song that's popular around Halloween) |
| 50% | NOG | 3 | Eggy drink that's popular around Christmas |
| 50% | DYE | 3 | Rit product that's popular around Easter |
| 47% | RIVER | 5 | Joni Mitchell song about heartbreak that's popular around the holidays but wasn't originally written as a Christmas song |
| 46% | SKELETON | 8 | This bony image is popular around Halloween |
| 45% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that was previously popular |
| 45% | HIT | 3 | Song that becomes very popular |
| 45% | MONSTERMASH | 11 | Classic Halloween song that’s “a graveyard smash” |
| 45% | MONSTERMASH | 11 | 1962 #1 hit that's a Halloween favorite |
| 44% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that was popular way back when |
| 43% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that was popular back in the day |
| 41% | MASH | 4 | "Monster ___," song by Bobby Pickett that can lift the spirits of any Halloween party |
| 40% | BREAKING | 8 | "___ Up Is Hard to Do," 1962 song by Neil Sedaka that topped the U.S. Billboard Hot 100 |
| 40% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that's not recent |
| 40% | MASH | 4 | "Monster ___" (song often heard around Halloween) |
| 40% | PEANUT | 6 | "___ Butter Jelly," Buckwheat Boyz's popular meme song referring sandwich-spreads that was featured on "Family Guy" |
| 39% | WATCHING | 8 | "Somebody's ___ Me," song by Rockwell that can lift the spirits of any Halloween party |
| 39% | HYMN | 4 | Song that's sung in church |
| 39% | ARIA | 4 | Song that's Italian for "air" |
| 39% | WITCHYWOMAN | 11 | Eagles song that a sorceress might sing on Halloween?: 2 wds. |
| 39% | SURETHING | 9 | Miguel song that became popular on TikTok in 2023 |
| 39% | GLEE | 4 | Popular TV show that features mashups of hit songs |
| 39% | HIT | 3 | Song that's high on the charts |
| 39% | DEEPCUT | 7 | Song that's only familiar to superfans |
| 39% | CAROL | 5 | Song that's typically sung in December |
| 38% | HIGHWAYTOHELL | 13 | AC/DC song that a devil might sing on Halloween?: 3 wds. |
| 38% | MASH | 4 | "Monster ___," 1962 song by Bobby Pickett with Halloween-inspired dance moves |
| 38% | BAKE | 4 | Cooking method using the oven that's very popular around fall |
| 38% | SOLO | 4 | Song that's sung by just one person |