| 100% | GREENSLEEVES | 12 | "My joy" and "my delight," in an old song |
| 70% | THEMANINTHEMOON | 15 | My sweetheart, in an old song |
| 64% | IRENE | 5 | In an old song, the "I'll see you in my dreams" girl |
| 56% | AUNT | 4 | Rhody, in an old song |
| 56% | PAL | 3 | Mary, in an old song |
| 56% | SAL | 3 | Mule in an old song |
| 55% | ADELINE | 7 | Sweet girl in an old song |
| 55% | SAL | 3 | Gal in an old song standard |
| 55% | CLANG | 5 | Trolley sound, in an old song |
| 54% | TRALEE | 6 | Mary's home, in an old song |
| 54% | OAKEN | 5 | Like a bucket in an old song |
| 54% | SUEDE | 5 | It's blue in an old song |
| 54% | ALLHERE | 7 | Like the gang, in an old song |
| 54% | ROWEDASHORE | 11 | Arrived like Michael in an old song? |
| 54% | SAL | 3 | Mule’s name in an old song |
| 54% | TON | 3 | 1 of 16, in an old song |
| 54% | TENCENTS | 8 | Cost of a dance, in an old song |
| 54% | LIGHTBROWN | 10 | Jeanie's hair color, in an old song |
| 54% | KATY | 4 | Woman's name stuttered in an old song |
| 54% | BEERBARREL | 10 | One was rolled out in an old song |
| 52% | MEETME | 6 | What to do "in St. Louis," in an old song |
| 52% | MOONRIVER | 9 | It's "wider than a mile," in an old song |
| 52% | KATY | 4 | "A maid with hair of gold," in an old song |
| 52% | IRENE | 5 | Woman who's bid good night in an old song |
| 52% | BALLGAME | 8 | *Something to "take me out to," in an old song |
| 52% | GEMOFTHEOCEAN | 13 | Columbia, in an old patriotic song |
| 52% | DINAH | 5 | Someone's in the kitchen with her, in an old song |
| 50% | SHE | 3 | Word after "does" and "doesn't" in an old ad slogan |
| 49% | PEANUT | 6 | "___ Butter Jelly Time" (novelty song in an old internet meme) |
| 49% | OLE | 3 | Old pronounced in an informal and humorous way |