| 100% | PONY | 4 | "My Little ___" (toy line and media franchise) |
| 100% | PONY | 4 | My Little ___, Hasbro toy line and media franchise |
| 60% | PONY | 4 | My Little ___ (kids' toy line) |
| 60% | PONY | 4 | My Little ___ (Hasbro toy line) |
| 60% | PONY | 4 | My Little ___, Hasbro toy line |
| 47% | PONY | 4 | My Little ___ (Hasbro toy) |
| 46% | HASBRO | 6 | My Little Pony toy brand |
| 45% | TOTO | 4 | The dog in the movie line "I'll get you, my pretty, and your little dog, too!" |
| 45% | PONY | 4 | "My Little ___" (Hasbro toy line) |
| 45% | DOLLS | 5 | My Little Pony toys, e.g. |
| 43% | PONY | 4 | My Little ___ (Hasbro toy with a mane to comb) |
| 40% | COZYCOUPE | 9 | Little Tikes' classic red and yellow toy car |
| 39% | MONSTER | 7 | My Pet __; a toy, book series and animated TV show |
| 38% | CAREBEARS | 9 | 1980s plush toy line that included Funshine and Love-a-Lot: 2 wds. |
| 38% | LPS | 3 | Hasbro's popular toy franchise and cartoon series: Abbr. |
| 38% | KID | 3 | "Diary of a Wimpy ___," book series and media franchise created by Jeff Kinney that follows a middle-schooler |
| 38% | ARLENE | 6 | "What's My Line" colleague of Bennett and Dorothy |
| 38% | ILL | 3 | "___ get you, my pretty, and your little dog, too!" |
| 38% | CSI | 3 | Anthony Zuiker media franchise that aired 797 episodes between October 2000 and March 2016 |
| 36% | STORY | 5 | "Toy ___," animated film franchise where Sheriff Woody and other toys come to life |
| 36% | YER | 3 | "__ Blues": Beatles song with the line "Even hate my rock and roll" |
| 35% | BUILDABEAR | 10 | Customizable toy franchise, and what a part of each starred answer can do |
| 35% | LEASH | 5 | Toy line? |
| 34% | WICKEDWITCH | 11 | She famously said, "I'll get you, my pretty, and your little dog, too!" |
| 33% | TOTO | 4 | The little dog of “I’ll get you, my pretty, and your little dog, too!” |
| 33% | WEEP | 4 | "Immortality," poem by Clare Harner with the line "Do not stand at my grave and ___" |
| 33% | BACK | 4 | "There's a little too much ___ and forth for my liking..." |
| 32% | SINKER | 6 | Hook, line and ___ |
| 32% | FILM | 4 | __ and Media Studies (Columbia department) |
| 31% | BEANIE | 6 | ___ Babies (plush toy line) |