| 100% | NANETTE | 7 | "No, No, ___" (Broadway musical of the 1920s) |
| 68% | PIPPIN | 6 | Broadway musical about the son of Charlemagne |
| 68% | WICKED | 6 | Broadway musical about the witches of Oz |
| 67% | SIX | 3 | Broadway musical about the wives of Henry VIII |
| 67% | RENT | 4 | Broadway musical with the song "Seasons of Love" |
| 66% | BANANAS | 7 | "Yes! We Have No ___" (novelty song of the 1920s) |
| 65% | BANANAS | 7 | "Yes! We Have No ___" (novelty hit song of the 1920s) |
| 65% | MAMMAMIA | 8 | Broadway musical featuring the songs of 39-Down (2 wds.) |
| 65% | PHANTOM | 7 | Broadway musical The __ of the Opera |
| 64% | KISMET | 6 | 1953 Broadway musical featuring the music of Alexander Borodin |
| 62% | SEASONS | 7 | "___ of Love" (song from the Broadway musical "Rent") |
| 62% | WOODS | 5 | "Into the ___," 2014 musical starring Anna Kendrick inspired by a Broadway musical of the same name |
| 62% | HORNE | 5 | Star of the 1957 Broadway musical "Jamaica" |
| 62% | WICKED | 6 | Broadway musical about the witches of Oz based on a novel by Gregory Maguire |
| 62% | HADESTOWN | 9 | Broadway musical based on the myth of Orpheus and Eurydice |
| 61% | FUNNYGIRL | 9 | 1964 Broadway musical about the life and career of 21-Across: 2 wds. |
| 61% | SIX | 3 | Broadway musical named for the number of wives of Henry VIII |
| 61% | BOOK | 4 | "The ___ of Mormon," Broadway musical that has toured the world |
| 61% | STYNE | 5 | Jule —, composer of the music for Broadway musical Gypsy |
| 59% | SMASH | 5 | 2012-2013 TV show about the creation of a Broadway musical |
| 59% | OKLAHOMA | 8 | State whose name is the title of a classic Broadway musical |
| 59% | RENTFREEZE | 10 | Super-cold spell on the set of a 1996 Broadway musical? |
| 59% | ERICIDLE | 8 | Monty Python member who wrote the book of Broadway musical Spamalot |
| 59% | ERIC | 4 | Monty Python member who wrote the book of Broadway musical Spamalot |
| 59% | KANDER | 6 | John —, American composer of the music for 1966 Broadway musical Cabaret |
| 58% | CHICA | 5 | Second-longest-running Broadway musical ever (after "The Phantom of the Opera") |
| 58% | IDLE | 4 | Eric —, Monty Python member who wrote the book of Broadway musical Spamalot |
| 58% | ERIC | 4 | & 4D Monty Python member who wrote the book of Broadway musical Spamalot |
| 58% | ERIC | 4 | & 13A Monty Python member who wrote the book of Broadway musical Spamalot |