| 100% | HEN | 3 | "One, Two, Buckle My Shoe" bird |
| 68% | ONE | 3 | "___, Two, Buckle My Shoe" |
| 67% | BUCKLE | 6 | One Two, __ My Shoe, children's counting song |
| 67% | ONE | 3 | "____, two, Buckle my shoe" |
| 66% | ONE | 3 | "___, two, buckle my shoe..." (nursery rhyme) |
| 65% | ONE | 3 | "___, Two, Buckle My Shoe," popular nursery rhyme |
| 64% | ONE | 3 | "___, Two, Buckle My Shoe" (words from a rhyme) |
| 64% | TWO | 3 | "One, ___, buckle my shoe" |
| 63% | BUCKLE | 6 | One, two __ my shoe, nursery rhyme |
| 61% | TWO | 3 | "One, ___, buckle my shoe ..." (nursery rhyme starter) |
| 54% | BUCKLE | 6 | Fasten, do up; One, two, __ my shoe |
| 49% | KILL | 4 | ___ two birds with one stone |
| 45% | KILL | 4 | "___ two birds with one stone" (achieve more at once) |
| 45% | TWO | 3 | Number rhymed with "buckle my shoe" |
| 41% | ADIDAS | 6 | Shoe brand originally run by two brothers, one of whom eventually split to form Puma |
| 41% | LISA | 4 | Simpson who said "Beneath my goody two shoes lie some very dark socks" |
| 40% | TOT | 3 | Goody Two-shoes, for one |
| 39% | PUN | 3 | "I threw away my golf shoes when I got a hole in one," e.g. |
| 38% | MYSHOE | 6 | What was buckled in the nursery rhyme One, two... |
| 38% | RENUMBER | 8 | Make one two |
| 38% | NUMBERS | 7 | One, two, three |
| 37% | LISASIMPSON | 11 | TV character who said "I learned that beneath my goody two shoes lie some very dark socks" |
| 37% | BALLS | 5 | One two of two-and-two |
| 37% | TEN | 3 | One + two + three + four |
| 37% | THRICE | 6 | One, two, three times |
| 37% | AMILE | 5 | "Walk ___ in my shoes" |
| 36% | LAP | 3 | One two-hundredth of the Daytona 500 |
| 36% | ONLY | 4 | My one and ___ |
| 36% | EITHER | 6 | One of two |
| 36% | CELTIC | 6 | Bird, for one |