| 100% | MARKLINNBAKER | 13 | "Perfect Strangers" actor who had a recurring role as mayoral aide Carlton Miller on "Blue Bloods" (2 wds.) |
| 72% | BOBBYCANNAVALE | 14 | "Nine Perfect Strangers" actor who had a recurring role as district attorney Charles Rosselini on "Blue Bloods" (2 wds.) |
| 61% | TREATWILLIAMS | 13 | "Everwood" actor who had a recurring role as former detective Lenny Ross on "Blue Bloods" (2 wds.) |
| 53% | CLIVESTANDEN | 12 | "Vikings" actor who has a recurring role as photojournalist Andre Ford on "The Morning Show" (2 wds.) |
| 52% | WILLARNETT | 10 | "Arrested Development" actor who has a recurring role as Alex's agent, Doug Klassen, on "The Morning Show" (2 wds.) |
| 52% | STEPHENFRY | 10 | "Jeeves and Wooster" actor who has a recurring role as UBA board member Leonard Cromwell on "The Morning Show" (2 wds.) |
| 51% | ADAMWEST | 8 | "Batman" actor who had a recurring voice role as himself on "Family Guy" (2 wds.) |
| 47% | DARYLHANNAH | 11 | Chicago-born actress who had a recurring role as Angelica Turing on the Netflix series "Sense8" (2 wds.) |
| 46% | STACY | 5 | Actor Keach who has a recurring role on "Blue Bloods" |
| 45% | MOSDEF | 6 | Rapper who had a recurring role on "Dexter": 2 wds. |
| 44% | MCRAE | 5 | Actor Mo who had a recurring role as Tyler on "Sons of Anarchy" |
| 44% | FRANKIEVALLI | 12 | Four Seasons lead vocalist who had a recurring role on "The Sopranos": 2 wds. |
| 40% | DYAN | 4 | Actress Cannon who had a recurring role as a judge on "Ally McBeal" |
| 40% | LONG | 4 | Actress Shelley who had a recurring role as DeDe Pritchett on "Modern Family" |
| 40% | STRITCH | 7 | Elaine who had a recurring role as Jack's mother on "30 Rock" |
| 40% | LONG | 4 | Actress Shelley who has a recurring role as DeDe Pritchett on "Modern Family" |
| 40% | LAHTI | 5 | Actress Christine who had a recurring role as Doris McGarrett on "Hawaii Five-0" |
| 40% | CAROL | 5 | Actress Burnett who had a recurring role as Eunice Higgins on "Mama's Family" |
| 40% | LAHTI | 5 | Actress Christine who has a recurring role as Doris McGarrett on "Hawaii Five-0" |
| 39% | DAVIDSCHWIMMER | 14 | Actor who had a capuchin monkey costar on "Friends": 2 wds. |
| 39% | NEAL | 4 | Actor McDonough who has a recurring role on "Yellowstone" |
| 39% | ELI | 3 | Actor Goree who has a recurring role on "Riverdale" |
| 39% | NOAHMILLS | 9 | Actor who learned to do some suturing for his role as a combat medic on NBC's "The Brave": 2 wds. |
| 39% | ALAN | 4 | Actor Alda who had a recurring role on "Ray Donovan" |
| 39% | WES | 3 | Actor Studi who had a recurring role on "Reservation Dogs" |
| 39% | CARL | 4 | Actor Weathers who has a recurring role on "The Mandalorian" |
| 38% | TREJO | 5 | Actor Danny who had a recurring role on "Sons of Anarchy" |
| 38% | OMAR | 4 | Actor Epps who had a recurring role on "This Is Us" |
| 38% | EPPS | 4 | Actor Omar who has a recurring role on "This Is Us" |
| 38% | PETER | 5 | Actor Gallagher who has a recurring role on "Grace and Frankie" |