| 100% | ABBY | 4 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with magical powers |
| 58% | BERT | 4 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with a unibrow |
| 58% | ELMO | 4 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with red fur |
| 58% | ELMO | 4 | Muppet with his own "world" on "Sesame Street" |
| 57% | BERT | 4 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with a pointy head |
| 57% | ERNIE | 5 | "Sesame Street" muppet with a striped shirt |
| 57% | ERNIE | 5 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with a rubber duck |
| 57% | ERNIE | 5 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with a rubber duckie |
| 57% | ERNIE | 5 | "Sesame Street" muppet with a rubber ducky |
| 57% | ELMO | 4 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with a pet goldfish |
| 57% | ERNIE | 5 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with a beloved rubber duckie |
| 57% | ELMO | 4 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with a high-pitched voice |
| 56% | ELSA | 4 | "Frozen" queen with magical powers |
| 56% | ELSA | 4 | "Frozen" character with magical powers |
| 56% | ABBYCADABBY | 11 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with wings and a magic wand |
| 56% | ELMO | 4 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with a pet goldfish named Dorothy |
| 55% | TALISMAN | 8 | Lucky charm, object with magical powers |
| 55% | ABBY | 4 | "Sesame Street" Muppet whose last name rhymes with her first |
| 54% | ERNIE | 5 | "Rubber Duckie" Sesame Street Muppet |
| 54% | SORCERER | 8 | A wizard with magical powers |
| 54% | ELSA | 4 | Disney princess with magical powers |
| 54% | ABBYCADABBY | 11 | "Sesame Street" Muppet with wings and a magic wand (2 wds.) |
| 54% | ELMO | 4 | Red "Sesame Street" Muppet with his own talk show |
| 54% | OSCAR | 5 | Sesame Street Muppet who sings "I Love Trash" |
| 53% | ZOE | 3 | Orange tutu-wearing Sesame Street Muppet |
| 53% | ELSA | 4 | Disney queen with magical wintry powers |
| 53% | ELSA | 4 | Disney queen with magical ice powers |
| 53% | SORCERER | 8 | Someone with magical powers, like a wizard |
| 52% | MCPHEE | 6 | Nanny with magical powers and a big bang |
| 51% | KERMITTHEFROG | 13 | "Sesame Street" Muppet who begins his roving reporter segments with "Hi-ho!" (3 wds.) |