| 100% | HOLLOW | 6 | "Sleepy ___," 1999 supernatural horror film starring Johnny Depp that has gothic elements |
| 59% | WOLF | 4 | "Brotherhood of the ___," supernatural horror film starring Samuel le Bihan that has gothic elements |
| 48% | PIT | 3 | "The ___ and the Pendulum," 1961 horror film starring Vincent Price that has gothic elements |
| 44% | HOLLOW | 6 | "Sleepy ___," 1999 gothic horror film directed by Tim Burton starring, Johnny Depp and Jeffrey Jones |
| 42% | THESIXTHSENSE | 13 | The 1999 supernatural horror film starring Bruce Willis that held the highest-grossing horror film record until 2017: 3 wds. |
| 37% | SLEEPY | 6 | With 32-Across, 1999 fantasy horror film directed by Tim Burton and starring Johnny Depp |
| 37% | SWEENEYTODD | 11 | "___: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street," 2007 musical horror film starring Johnny Depp which was directed by Tim Burton: 2 wds. |
| 36% | VEIL | 4 | "The ___," 2016 supernatural horror film directed by Phil Joanou that stars Jessica Alba |
| 33% | DARKSHADOWS | 11 | 2012 film starring Johnny Depp as a bloodsucker |
| 33% | RING | 4 | "The ___," 2002 supernatural horror film starring Naomi Watts |
| 32% | LONE | 4 | "The ___ Ranger," 2013 western action film starring Johnny Depp |
| 32% | EDWARD | 6 | "___ Scissorhands," 1990 film starring Johnny Depp and Winona Ryder |
| 32% | SLEEPYHOLLOW | 12 | 1999 horror film directed by Tim Burton, with Johnny Depp as constable Ichabod Crane: 2 wds. |
| 32% | ELM | 3 | "A Nightmare on ___ Street," 1984 slasher film starring Johnny Depp |
| 32% | TOURIST | 7 | The —, 2010 action film starring Johnny Depp and Angelina Jolie |
| 32% | MORTDECAI | 9 | 2015 action-comedy film starring Johnny Depp in the title role |
| 32% | SEMATARY | 8 | "Pet ___," 80s supernatural horror film starring Dale Midkiff and Miko Hughes |
| 30% | DONNIE | 6 | Johnny Depp starrer crime drama film "___ Brasco" |
| 30% | BEETLEJUICE | 11 | 1988 Tim Burton comedy/horror film starring 18-Across and 30-Across that has a 2024 sequel |
| 30% | EDWOOD | 6 | 1994 black-and-white biographical film starring Johnny Depp as the title director: 2 wds. |
| 30% | SLEEPYHOLLOW | 12 | 1999 Johnny Depp film |
| 30% | STIGMATA | 8 | 1999 horror film starring Patricia Arquette and Gabriel Byrne |
| 29% | THEBLAIRWITCH | 13 | "___ Project," 1999 supernatural horror film about three filmmakers who film a documentary about a local legend: 3 wds. |
| 29% | UNBREAKABLE | 11 | The 2000 supernatural horror film starring Bruce Willis which was also the first of the "Eastrail 177 trilogy" |
| 29% | THEOTHERS | 9 | 2001 gothic horror film starring Nicole Kidman |
| 28% | YOU | 3 | "___ Should Have Left," American psychological horror film starring Amanda Seyfried that had a digital release in 2020 |
| 28% | THEBLAIR | 8 | & 22A 1999 horror film starring Heather Donahue |
| 28% | ACTIVITY | 8 | "Paranormal ___," 2007 supernatural horror film that is centered around camera footages in a haunted house |
| 28% | DARK | 4 | "___ Shadows," soap opera starring Jonathan Frid that has fantastical characters and Gothic elements |
| 28% | ONCE | 4 | 2003 action film starring Antonio Banderas, Salma Hayek and Johnny Depp |