| 100% | NEW | 3 | "Something old, something ___ ..." |
| 100% | TESTAMENT | 9 | Something Old, something New? |
| 99% | RELIC | 5 | Something old |
| 99% | BORROWED | 8 | Something old, something new, something __ |
| 95% | ACOW | 4 | Something Old MacDonald had |
| 93% | RENEW | 5 | Replace something old |
| 93% | BORROWED | 8 | Somethings old, new, __, and blue |
| 91% | REENACT | 7 | Put on something old? |
| 89% | VINTAGE | 7 | Something old that is of high quality |
| 89% | RETRONYM | 8 | New word for something old |
| 89% | INDENTION | 9 | Something older authors often start paragraphs with |
| 86% | LORE | 4 | Something under elder care |
| 85% | BORROWED | 8 | "Something old, something new, something ___ ..." (wedding items) |
| 84% | PARADISE | 8 | Something lost in old literature |
| 84% | ONER | 4 | Something unique, in old slang |
| 82% | RETRO | 5 | Like something old that's back in style |
| 82% | MODERN | 6 | Something now, not antique or old |
| 82% | RETRO | 5 | Like something older that's in vogue again |
| 82% | ANTIQUE | 7 | Something that is old and collectible |
| 80% | RUSTYNAIL | 9 | Something found in an old board, maybe |
| 80% | OFAGE | 5 | Old enough to do something |
| 80% | AGE | 3 | Something that some older people lie about |
| 79% | ONER | 4 | Old slang for something extraordinary |
| 77% | CHAW | 4 | Something in the mouth of an old pitcher? |
| 77% | ODE | 3 | Old-fashioned poem that celebrates something |
| 75% | ADZE | 4 | Something an old Tlingit boat builder might have used |
| 75% | AFEARED | 7 | Old term for being afraid of something |
| 75% | OILLAMP | 7 | Old-fashioned light source, burns something greasy |
| 75% | GRAPE | 5 | Old king gets primate something to eat |
| 73% | NEW | 3 | "Something old, something ___, something borrowed, something blue," common superstitious saying related to weddings |