| 100% | SARA | 4 | "Storms are brewin'" in her eyes, in a 1986 #1 hit |
| 58% | ANGIE | 5 | She's asked "When will those clouds all disappear?" in a 1973 #1 hit |
| 54% | SHEILA | 6 | "Her cheeks are rosy, she looks a little nosey" girl in a 1962 #1 hit |
| 54% | MARIAELENA | 10 | She was "the answer to a prayer" in a 1941 #1 Jimmy Dorsey hit |
| 51% | RHONDA | 6 | Her help was solicited in a hit song |
| 49% | EYEOFTHETIGER | 13 | Survivor song that was a No. 1 hit in 1982 (4 wds.) |
| 49% | AGUILERA | 8 | Genie in a Bottle was one of her hits: Christina __ |
| 48% | LORDE | 5 | Her No. 1 hit "Royals" was inspired by a 1976 photo of George Brett |
| 48% | DONTYOUWANTME | 13 | The Human League song that was a No. 1 hit in 1982 (4 wds.) |
| 48% | RHONDA | 6 | The "you" in "you caught my eye" in a 1965 #1 hit |
| 47% | MYRTLEWILSON | 12 | She is killed in a hit-and-run accident in "The Great Gatsby": 2 wds. |
| 47% | EBONYANDIVORY | 13 | Paul McCartney and Stevie Wonder song that was a No. 1 hit in 1982 (3 wds.) |
| 47% | WAP | 3 | 2020 No. 1 hit whose title acronym is compared to “macaroni in a pot” |
| 46% | MYGUY | 5 | Fellow "I can't be torn apart from," in a 1964 #1 hit |
| 46% | OAKTREE | 7 | Where a yellow ribbon is tied in a 1973 #1 hit |
| 46% | CLOSETOYOU | 10 | Where the Carpenters "long to be" in a 1970 #1 hit |
| 46% | SARA | 4 | Title girl in a 1986 Starship hit |
| 45% | MARYWELLS | 9 | Smokey Robinson's My Guy was a hit for her in 1964 |
| 45% | AGORAHILLS | 10 | 2023 Doja Cat hit whose title is a tribute to a town she lived in: 2 wds. |
| 44% | OHS | 3 | 17 of them are sung before "my gosh" in a 2010 #1 Usher hit |
| 44% | MONDAY | 6 | "Manic" time in a 1986 hit |
| 43% | REESE | 5 | Her "Don't You Know" was a #1 R & B hit |
| 43% | MANIC | 5 | Type of Monday that The Bangles described in a 1986 hit |
| 43% | SHEILA | 6 | Girl with blue eyes and a ponytail, in a 1962 #1 hit |
| 43% | MONTERO | 7 | 2021 #1 hit song that was teased in a Super Bowl commercial |
| 43% | RIO | 3 | She “dances on the sand” in a Duran Duran hit |
| 42% | RUNNINGSCARED | 13 | 1961 Roy Orbison hit that has the same title as, but is not featured in, a 1986 Gregory Hines/Billy Crystal film (2 wds.) |
| 42% | RHONDA | 6 | She "caught my eye" in a Beach Boys song |
| 42% | EWE | 3 | She might be found in a flock |
| 41% | GTO | 3 | It was "really lookin' fine" in a 1964 pop hit |