| 100% | WEKNOW | 6 | "That's no surprise to any of us" |
| 55% | IKNOW | 5 | "That's no surprise to me" |
| 55% | IKNEW | 5 | "That's no surprise to me" |
| 49% | MENSA | 5 | Organization that no U.S. president has ever belonged to |
| 49% | OHO | 3 | Cry of surprise that's similar to "Aha!" |
| 49% | OHO | 3 | Cry of surprise that's similar to Aha! |
| 49% | YIKES | 5 | Expression of surprise that's similar to "Eek!" |
| 48% | ISERE | 5 | Ship that brought the Statue of Liberty to the U.S. |
| 48% | OHO | 3 | Cry of surprise that's similar to 27-Across |
| 48% | ISERE | 5 | French frigate that carried the Statue of Liberty to the U.S. |
| 48% | WHOA | 4 | Expression of surprise that's similar to "Hold your horses!" |
| 45% | IKNEWIT | 7 | "That was no surprise to me": 3 wds. |
| 45% | PHEW | 4 | Exclamation of relief and surprise that's similar to "That was close!" |
| 45% | OURS | 4 | Like things that belong to both of us |
| 44% | KNEW | 4 | "I ___ it all the time!" ("It's no surprise to me") |
| 44% | HUMAN | 5 | Any of us |
| 43% | HOME | 4 | There's no place like it ... or a word that can precede either half of the answer to each starred clue |
| 43% | OLDLATIN | 8 | Source of many English words that come to us via French |
| 43% | PEARL | 5 | With 4 Down, site of the attack that on today's date in 1941 lead to the US entering WWII |
| 42% | IKNOW | 5 | "That's no surprise" |
| 42% | ITFIGURES | 9 | "That's no surprise" |
| 42% | MONEY | 5 | "A blessing that is of no advantage to us excepting when we part with it," according to Ambrose Bierce |
| 42% | VIDEONASTY | 10 | Any of several graphic horror films that sparked a moral panic in the U.K. in the eighties, colloquially |
| 42% | INBED | 5 | Words that can be added to the end of any fortune cookie, it's said |
| 41% | MARINER | 7 | Any of a series of US space probes launched between 1962 and 1971 that took photographs of Mars and Venus |
| 41% | ONE | 3 | Number of U.S. states without any straight borders |
| 41% | THREE | 5 | Number of U.S. states that start with "C" |
| 41% | LINE | 4 | No surprise to a Disney World arrival |
| 41% | PEST | 4 | Insect that's up to no good? |
| 41% | ATTORNEY | 8 | Any one of 25 U.S. presidents |