| 100% | ONEI | 4 | "The ___ Gave My Heart To" (1997 Aaliyah hit) |
| 84% | ONEI | 4 | "The ___ Gave My Heart To" (1997 pop hit) |
| 83% | ONEI | 4 | "The ___ Gave My Heart To" (1997 Aaliyah song): 2 wds. |
| 81% | IGAVE | 5 | 1997 Aaliyah hit "The One ___ My Heart To" |
| 81% | ONEI | 4 | Aaliyah hit "The ___ Gave My Heart To" |
| 78% | ONEI | 4 | "The ___ Gave My Heart To" (Aaliyah hit) |
| 75% | ONEI | 4 | “The ___ Gave My Heart To” (ballad by Aaliyah) |
| 68% | ONEI | 4 | Aaliyah's "The ___ Gave My Heart To" (2 wds.) |
| 49% | ILEFT | 5 | "___ My Heart at the Stage Door Canteen" (1942 hit) |
| 47% | ODE | 3 | "___ to My Family" (1994 hit for the Cranberries) |
| 44% | EVERYMOTHERSSON | 15 | Group with the 1967 hit "Come On Down to My Boat" |
| 44% | SAVAGE | 6 | __ Garden had a 1997 hit with To The Moon and Back |
| 43% | CHEF | 4 | "Give my compliments to the ___" |
| 42% | PIPERS | 6 | "On the eleventh day of Christmas, my true love gave to me, eleven ___ piping ..." |
| 42% | IMA | 3 | Words repeated as part of the chorus to Meredith Brooks's 1997 hit "Bitch" |
| 41% | ODE | 3 | "__ to My Family": 1994 hit for The Cranberries |
| 41% | ESOBESO | 7 | 1962 hit with the lyric "Like the samba sound, my heart begins to pound" |
| 40% | PEGO | 4 | "_____ My Heart" (1913 hit) |
| 40% | ILOST | 5 | "___ my heart to her" (fell in love): 2 wds. |
| 40% | STAYWITHME | 10 | 2014 hit with the lyric “I don’t want you to leave, will you hold my hand?” |
| 40% | THIRDEYEBLIND | 13 | Band with the 1997 hit "Semi-Charmed Life" … or a phonetic hint to this puzzle's theme |
| 39% | OFT | 3 | "Thy friendship ___ has made my heart to ache": Blake |
| 39% | UPTOWNFUNK | 10 | 2014 Mark Ronson hit that later had to give members of the Gap Band songwriting credits: 2 wds. |
| 39% | CROSS | 5 | "___ my heart and hope to die" |
| 39% | CROSS | 5 | "___ my heart (and hope to die)" |
| 39% | ITTO | 4 | "Tell ___ My Heart" (1987 hit) |
| 39% | ASSURE | 6 | Give heart to |
| 39% | CECILIA | 7 | 1970 hit with the lyric "I'm down on my knees, / I'm begging you please to come home" |
| 38% | DIE | 3 | "Cross my heart and hope to ___!" |
| 38% | AND | 3 | "Cross my heart ___ hope to die" |