| 100% | DISCOVERY | 9 | "The Greatest ___," a song from Elton John's acclaimed self-titled album |
| 47% | WHATSGOINGON | 12 | Title song from the 1971 album that Rolling Stone named the greatest of all time |
| 45% | CROCODILEROCK | 13 | Elton John song on "Don't Shoot Me I'm Only the Piano Player" whose title ends with a music genre (2 wds.) |
| 43% | WATER | 5 | "Madman Across the ___," 1971 song by Elton John from the eponymous album |
| 41% | WONDERWALL | 10 | A hit song by English band Oasis from their second album "(What's the Story) Morning Glory" |
| 41% | STORY | 5 | "Perfect ___," 2016 song from the eponymously titled album by Idina Menzel |
| 41% | CROCODILEROCK | 13 | 1972 Elton John song with a sharp-toothed title: 2 wds. |
| 41% | UNKNOWN | 7 | A song from Disney's Frozen 2, Into the __ |
| 40% | GIRLONFIRE | 10 | Song from Alicia Keys' fifth studio album which was a commercial hit with over 4 million paid downloads in the U.S.: 3 wds. |
| 40% | ONE | 3 | "Be the ___," song by Dua Lipa from her self-titled debut album |
| 40% | COMPASS | 7 | 2013 song by Lady A from the album "Golden" |
| 40% | OBLADI | 6 | Start of a Beatles title from the "White Album" |
| 40% | ALMOST | 6 | Song by the band DNCE from their self-titled debut album released in 2016 |
| 40% | UNSWEET | 7 | Song by the band DNCE from their self-titled debut album released in 2016 |
| 40% | NASA | 4 | Hit song by Ariana Grande from her 2019 album whose title is named after the U.S. space agency |
| 39% | PICTURE | 7 | The Big __, 1997 album from Elton John |
| 39% | HONKYCAT | 8 | 1972 Elton John song where the title character is told to "get back": 2 wds. |
| 39% | IMAGINE | 7 | First song on a John Lennon album of the same name |
| 39% | ROCKET | 6 | "___ Man," Elton John number that is a popular wake-up song aboard the International Space Station |
| 39% | FRIDAY | 6 | "___ Night," 2011 song by Lady A from the album "Own the Night" |
| 39% | HONEY | 5 | "American ___," 2010 song by Lady A from the album "Need You Now" |
| 39% | ANNA | 4 | Title girl in a song on the first Beatles album |
| 38% | HEREANDNOW | 10 | Title song from 30-Across's 2020 album that was also the name of his 2022 tour (3 wds.) |
| 38% | COAST | 5 | "Songs from the West ___," 2001 album by Elton with the Grammy-nominated song "I Want Love" |
| 38% | COME | 4 | "___ On Eileen," a song by the '80s band Dexy Midnight Runners from their album "Too-Rye-Ay" |
| 38% | WANTED | 6 | "___ You More," 2012 song by Lady A from the album "Own the Night" |
| 38% | LOVE | 4 | "Be Patient With My ___," 2019 song by Lady A from the album "Ocean" |
| 38% | WHITERABBIT | 11 | Bunny from Wonderland, or the title of a Jefferson Airplane song: 2 wds. |
| 38% | AIDA | 4 | Elton John/Tim Rice opera adaptation that featured a #2 song on the Adult Contemporary chart ("Written in the Stars") |
| 38% | CHERISH | 7 | Top 5 hit song from Madonna's "Like a Prayer" album |