| 100% | PLENTY | 6 | "There are ___ of fish in the sea" |
| 76% | SEA | 3 | "There are plenty of fish in the ___" |
| 71% | SALTS | 5 | There are a lot of ___ in the seas making them saline |
| 70% | ATIDE | 5 | There is ___ in the affairs of men ... |
| 69% | HOUSES | 6 | There are 12 of these (domiciles) in the horoscope |
| 69% | SEA | 3 | "There are plenty of other fish in the ___" |
| 66% | STEPS | 5 | There are 393 in the staircase going up the Statue of Liberty |
| 66% | SEA | 3 | "There's plenty of fish in the ___." |
| 66% | SEA | 3 | "There's plenty of fish in the ___" |
| 65% | CARIBBEAN | 9 | Sea in which the island of Cozumel is located |
| 65% | CARIBBEAN | 9 | Sea in which the island of Redonda is found |
| 64% | DODECANESE | 10 | Group of islands in the Aegean Sea whose capital is Rhodes |
| 64% | STARS | 5 | There are seven of them in the Big Dipper |
| 63% | BIRDS | 5 | There are two, as the expression goes, in each of 16- and 55-Across |
| 63% | SEA | 3 | Plenty of fish in the ___ |
| 63% | LOLLAND | 7 | Island of Denmark in the Baltic Sea whose largest town is Nakskov |
| 62% | ELBA | 4 | ___ Island, Italian island in the Tyrrhenian Sea known to be Napoleon's place of exile |
| 61% | GTILES | 6 | The only pieces there are exactly three of in Scrabble |
| 61% | NET | 3 | Tool to catch many fish in the sea |
| 60% | ATIDE | 5 | "There is __ in the affairs of men": Brutus |
| 58% | NEMO | 4 | Fish in the title of a 2003 animated movie |
| 58% | BRIDES | 6 | There are more of these in the U.S. in October than any other month, surprisingly |
| 58% | ISLET | 5 | Tiny spot of land in the sea |
| 58% | ISLET | 5 | Tiny bit of land in the sea |
| 58% | ISLE | 4 | Small piece of land in the sea |
| 58% | ISLETS | 6 | Tiny dots of land in the sea |
| 58% | ADMIRALCRUNCH | 13 | Mascot "born in the Sea of Milk" |
| 58% | ISLET | 5 | Teeny bit of land in the sea |
| 58% | ISLES | 5 | Small bits of land in the sea |
| 58% | ISLET | 5 | Small bit of land in the sea |