| 100% | STORYOFMYLIFE | 13 | "This *always* happens to me" |
| 100% | EVERYTIME | 9 | "Ugh, this always happens to me!" |
| 93% | STORYOFMYLIFE | 13 | "This ALWAYS happens to me" |
| 66% | NOTAGAIN | 8 | "Why does this keep happening to me?!": 2 wds. |
| 65% | AARGH | 5 | "Why is this happening to me?!" |
| 64% | GAH | 3 | "Why is this happening to me?!" cry |
| 63% | CANT | 4 | "I ___ believe this happened to me" |
| 63% | GAH | 3 | “Why is this happening to me?!” |
| 61% | OHNO | 4 | "I can't believe this is happening to me!": 2 wds. |
| 60% | ICANRELATE | 10 | "Same thing happened to me" |
| 60% | IKNOWTHEFEELING | 15 | ''Something similar happened to me'' |
| 58% | SAME | 4 | “That happened to me, too” |
| 57% | IMDUE | 5 | "It should happen to me soon" |
| 56% | TOME | 4 | "Why does this always happen ___?": 2 wds. |
| 55% | DONTQUOTEMEONTHIS | 17 | Mrs. B you'll die when you hear what happened to "me" this summer! |
| 55% | ENVY | 4 | "It should have happened to me instead" feeling |
| 51% | GATS | 4 | “I never thought it could happen, this rappin’ stuff / I was too used to packin’ ___ and stuff”: the Notorious B.I.G. |
| 51% | ITWAS | 5 | "___ an accident!" ("I didn't mean for this to happen!"): 2 wds. |
| 51% | ISNEW | 5 | “This ___ to me” (“Never seen this before”) |
| 49% | PAINS | 5 | "It ___ me to say this …" |
| 49% | GOLDRING | 8 | My true love gave to me five of this item |
| 49% | STOLEN | 6 | This happened to the Mona Lisa in 1911 |
| 49% | ICARE | 5 | "You can always talk to me" |
| 48% | PAINS | 5 | "It ___ me to say this, but . . ." |
| 48% | IMONIT | 6 | "Leave this to me!" |
| 48% | ONI | 3 | "Leave this to me" |
| 48% | STEPASIDE | 9 | "Leave this to me" |
| 48% | ILLDOIT | 7 | "Leave this to me!" |
| 48% | SUBCONTRACTED | 13 | Outsourced, and what happened to the circled letters in this puzzle |
| 48% | OKLAHOMA | 8 | I Cain't Say No to this US state |