| 100% | CAN | 3 | "Two ___ play that game!" |
| 100% | CAN | 3 | "Two ____ play that game!" |
| 83% | TWO | 3 | "___ can play that game!" |
| 83% | TWO | 3 | "___ can play that game" |
| 78% | CAN | 3 | "Two ___ play at that game!" |
| 78% | CAN | 3 | "Two ___ play at that game" |
| 78% | PUN | 3 | "Toucan play that game," e.g. |
| 77% | TWO | 3 | "___ Can Play That Game" (2001 romantic comedy) |
| 75% | KICKOFF | 7 | Play that starts a football game |
| 73% | PLEASEDONTGO | 12 | "I'm begging you, let's not play that game!" |
| 71% | ROLE | 4 | Something played that's not a game |
| 70% | IHAVENTACLUE | 12 | "We can't play that game unless we borrow someone else's" |
| 69% | RAINOUT | 7 | Game that can't be played |
| 68% | THERISKISTOOHIGH | 16 | "We can't play that game - I can't reach it on our shelf!" |
| 68% | ONEONONE | 8 | Hall & Oates hit with the lyric "I wanna play that game tonight" (3 wds.) |
| 67% | UNO | 3 | Game that has Draw Two and Reverse cards |
| 67% | 52PICKUP | 8 | Game that people rarely agree to play twice |
| 67% | MONOPOLY | 8 | Game that contains $20,580 in play money |
| 67% | TWO | 3 | Number that "can play that game" |
| 67% | LIMBO | 5 | Game that might be played with a stick |
| 67% | CANASTA | 7 | Rummy game played with two decks |
| 66% | AMFM | 4 | Two bands that might let you play many bands |
| 65% | POLO | 4 | Game that can be played on bicycles or elephants |
| 65% | EUCHRE | 6 | Game that introduced the joker into modern playing cards |
| 65% | ESPYS | 5 | Best Play and Best Game, for two |
| 65% | SKAT | 4 | Card game played without twos through sixes |
| 64% | REMOTE | 6 | Game play that is done from afar, on the internet |
| 64% | JENGA | 5 | Game requiring steady hands that's often played while drinking |
| 64% | UNO | 3 | Game that can't be played solitaire, despite its name |
| 64% | ISPY | 4 | Game that can be played with whatever’s lying around |