| 100% | FOR | 3 | "V ___ Vendetta," 2006 dystopian political thriller, directed by James McTeigue that stars Natalie Portman |
| 46% | SWAN | 4 | "Black ___," 2010 psychological thriller, directed by Darren Aronofsky that stars Natalie Portman |
| 40% | JACKIE | 6 | 2016 biographical drama film directed by Pablo Larrain that stars Natalie Portman |
| 39% | CLOSER | 6 | 2004 romantic drama film directed by Mike Nichols that stars Natalie Portman alongside Julia Roberts |
| 36% | STATE | 5 | "Garden ___," 2004 romantic comedy-drama film directed by Zach Braff that stars Natalie Portman |
| 34% | ARGO | 4 | 2012 political thriller starring and directed by Ben Affleck |
| 34% | ADASTRA | 7 | Space thriller directed by James Gray starring 1-Down/50-Down, 6-Down, and Liv Tyler (2 wds.) |
| 31% | GASLIT | 6 | 2022 political thriller series starring Julia Roberts that was inspired by the podcast "Slow Burn" |
| 31% | THEPRESTIGE | 11 | 2006 psychological thriller directed by Christopher Nolan that follows the story of rival magicians: 2 wds. |
| 29% | ARGO | 4 | 2012 film thriller directed by and starring Ben Affleck |
| 28% | PLAYMISTYFORME | 14 | 1971 thriller directed by and starring Clint Eastwood: 4 wds. |
| 28% | TENET | 5 | 2020 thriller directed by Christopher Nolan starring John David Washington |
| 28% | PLAY | 4 | & 7D 1971 film thriller directed by and starring Clint Eastwood |
| 28% | DEAD | 4 | & 12D 1991 film thriller directed by and starring Kenneth Branagh |
| 28% | BLACKSWAN | 9 | 2010 psychological thriller film starring Natalie Portman which is based on an original story by Heinz: 2 wds. |
| 28% | SCANDAL | 7 | Political thriller created by Shonda Rhimes starring Kerry Washington |
| 28% | THOR | 4 | "___: The Dark World," 2013 superhero film based on a Marvel Comics character that stars Natalie Portman |
| 27% | TRAININGDAY | 11 | 2001 crime thriller directed by 43-Across starring Denzel Washington (2 wds.) |
| 27% | THEEQUALIZER | 12 | 2014 crime thriller directed by 43-Across starring Denzel Washington (2 wds.) |
| 27% | AMERICANME | 10 | 1992 film directed by and starring Edward James Olmos |
| 27% | ARGO | 4 | 2012 spy thriller directed by and starring Ben Affleck, based on a true story |
| 26% | INSIDEMAN | 9 | 2006 crime thriller starring Denzel Washington and directed by Spike Lee: 2 wds. |
| 26% | VICE | 4 | 2018 political drama directed by Adam McKay starring Sam Rockwell |
| 26% | SWAN | 4 | "Black ___," 2010 psychological horror film starring Natalie Portman that's one of the highest-grossing independent films |
| 26% | INSIDIOUS | 9 | 2010 supernatural horror film directed by James Wan starring Patrick Wilson about ghosts in an astral dimension |
| 26% | BLUE | 4 | "Into the ___," 2005 action thriller film directed by John Stockwell that stars Jessica Alba |
| 25% | WRATHOFMAN | 10 | 2021 action thriller directed by 17-Across and starring 26-Across (3 wds.) |
| 25% | STREET | 6 | "The ___ of Sorrow," 1925 film directed by Georg Wilhelm Pabst that stars Greta Garbo |
| 25% | ANNIHILATION | 12 | 2018 thriller starring Natalie Portman as a biologist entering an isolated zone |